Forensic deliberations on ‘purposeful metaphor’
The concept of ‘purposeful metaphor’ is proposed as an alternative to ‘deliberate metaphor’ (Steen, 2008) in providing a theory of metaphor in discourse and communication. The case for ‘purposeful metaphor’ is framed within a discussion of intentionality in a murder trial. It is argued that ‘deliberateness’ originates in epistemologies based in language use, but is not valid for epistemologies that distinguish between conscious and unconscious thought process; in literary studies it is known as the ‘intentional fallacy’. However, considerations of intention are relevant in critical metaphor analysis that seeks insight into the social and political motivation of metaphor. Insights from Speech Act Theory and rhetorical theory suggest that ‘deliberate metaphor’ could be modified to ‘purposeful metaphor’ because we conceptualise ‘purpose’ in terms of a SOURCE (or idea), a PATH (or rhetorical plan) to realise a GOAL (or rhetorical outcome). ‘Purposeful metaphor’ therefore integrates the source (or idea behind) path, (or rhetorical plan), and goal, (or rhetorical outcome) of metaphor, while ‘deliberate metaphor’ only profiles its inception. Illustrations are given of how ‘purposeful metaphor’ contributes to an explanation of metaphor use in political and legal discourse, and other persuasive genres. Linguistic evidence for purposefulness is in the interaction between textually complex use of metaphor and contextual features such as political purpose or describing medical conditions.
Published online: 07 September 2012
https://doi.org/10.1075/msw.2.1.01cha
https://doi.org/10.1075/msw.2.1.01cha
Cited by
Cited by 25 other publications
Anderson, J., Y. Zhu, J. Zhuang, J.C. Nelson, M.J. Bresnahan & X. Yan
Beger, Anke
Beger, Anke & Thomas H. Smith
Bogetić, Ksenija
Crespo-Fernández, Eliecer
Dewandre, Nicole G. & Orsolya Gulyas
Dewandre*, Nicole & Orsolya Gulyás
Donaldson, Jonan Phillip & Ayana Allen-Handy
Ferrari, Federica
Gibbs, Raymond W.
Negrea-Busuioc, Elena & L. David Ritchie
Pilgram, Roosmaryn & Lotte van Poppel
Poppi, Fabio & Peter Kravanja
Poppi, Fabio I. M., Marianna Bolognesi & Amitash Ojha
Poppi, Fabio Indìo Massimo & Salvatore Di Piazza
Poppi, Fabio Indìo Massimo & Peter Kravanja
Poppi, Fabio Indìo Massimo, Giovanni A. Travaglino & Salvatore Di Piazza
Reijnierse, W. Gudrun, Christian Burgers, Tina Krennmayr & Gerard J. Steen
Salis, Pietro & Francesca Ervas
Schoor, Carola
Steen, Gerard
Thonus, Terese & Beth L. Hewett
Ureña Gómez-Moreno, José Manuel
van Poppel, Lotte
van Poppel, Lotte
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 10 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.