Article in:
Narrative Inquiry: Online-First Articles

Migrant doctors’ narratives about patients

A study of professional identity in Chile and Hong Kong

| Universidad Católica del Maule
| The University of Hong Kong
Narratives of personal and vicarious experience are part and parcel of being a doctor, as doctors routinely (re)interpret and (re)tell patients’ narratives when reflecting on clinical cases. Taking an interest in migrant doctors’ self-initiated narratives about patients in doctor-researcher interviews about cultural transitions, this study examines over thirty hours of audio-recordings of forty semi-structured interviews conducted as part of a collaborative project in Chile and Hong Kong. The study explores how migrant doctors construct their professional ‘self’ through narratives about patients, and how these narratives help migrant doctors legitimise their arguments and professional stance in criticizing cultural and societal attitudes towards health and illness, and the professional practices of local doctors. Finally, the paper reflects on the ways in which migrant doctors’ identity positionings provide space for the creation of a “symbolic territory” in which the practices of migrant doctors co-exist within the boundaries of the practices of local doctors in the host culture.
Keywords: narratives of vicarious experience, cultural transitions, societal attitudes to health, criticism, discourse
Article outline
  • Introduction
  • Narratives of personal and vicarious experience
  • Conceptualising identity in cultural transitions
  • Data and method
  • Analysis
  • Discussion and conclusions
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 23 December 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/ni.21038.laz
References
Bhabha, H.
(1995) Unpacking my library again. The Journal of the Midwest Modern Language Association, 28 (1), 5–18. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bamberg, M., & Georgakopoulou, A.
(2008) Small stories as a new perspective in narrative and identity analysis. Text & Talk, 28 (3), 377–396. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Baran, D.
(2018) Narratives of migration on Facebook: Belonging and identity among former fellow refugees. Language in Society, 47 (2), 245–268. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Barone, S., & Lazzaro-Salazar, M.
(2016) Walking the fine line between criticism and constructive feedback: A discursive analytic perspective of doctors’ peer assessment. Presented in Sociolinguistics Symposium, Universidad de Murcia , Spain, 15–18 June.
Barone, S. and Lazzaro-Salazar, M.
(2015) ‘Forty bucks is forty bucks’: An analysis of a medical doctor’s professional identity. Journal of Language and Communication, 43 1, 27–34. 41. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bell, J.
(1999) Redefining national identity in Uzbekistan: symbolic tensions in Tashkent’s official public landscape. Ecumene, 6 (2), 183–213. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bourdieu, P.
(1979) La distinction. Critique sociale du jugement. Editions de Minuit.Google Scholar
(1998) La domination masculine. Editions du Seuil.Google Scholar
Bucholtz, M., & Hall, K.
(2010) Locating Identity in Language. In Carmen Llamas and Dominic Watt (Eds.), Language and identities (pp. 18–28). Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Charon, R.
(2001) Narrative medicine: A model for empathy, reflection, profession, and trust. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 286 (15): 1897–1902. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Clynes, M., & Raftery, S.
(2008) Feedback: an essential element of student learning in clinical practice. Nurse Education in Practice, 8 (6), 405–411. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Conle, C., Li, X., & Tan, J.
(2002) Connecting vicarious experience to practice. Curriculum Inquiry, 32 (4), 429–452. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Declercq, J., & Jacobs, G.
(2019) “It’s such a great story it sells itself”? Narratives of vicarious experience in a European pharmaceutical company. Journal of Pragmatics, 152 1, 89–102. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
De Fina, A.
(2003) Identity in Narrative: A study of immigrant discourse. John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2011) Researcher and informant roles in narrative interactions: Constructions of belonging and foreign-ness. Language in Society, 40 (1), 27–38. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Dey, I.
(2005) Qualitative data analysis: A user friendly guide for social scientists. Routledge.Google Scholar
Foucault, M.
(1988) Technologies of the self. University of Massachusetts Press.Google Scholar
Fragkos, K.
(2016) Reflective Practice in Healthcare Education: An Umbrella Review. Education Sciences, 6 (3), 27. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Georgakopoulou, A.
(2006) Thinking big with small stories in narrative and identity analysis. Narrative Inquiry, 16 (1), 122–130. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2007) Small stories, interaction and identities. John Benjamins Publishing. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Glenn, P.
(2009) Laughter in interaction. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Goodman, L.
(1961) Snowball sampling. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 148–170. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hale, H., & de Abreu, G.
(2010) Drawing on the notion of symbolic resources in exploring the development of cultural identities in immigrant transitions. Culture & Psychology, 16 (3), 395–415. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hall, J.
(2012) Teaching and researching language and culture. Pearson Education.Google Scholar
Haakana, M.
(2002) Laughter in medical interaction: From quantification to analysis, and back. Journal of Sociolinguistics, 6 (2), 207–235. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hatavara, M., & Mildorf, J.
(2017) Fictionality, Narrative Modes, and Vicarious Storytelling. Style, 51 1, 391–408. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hogg, M., & Terry, D.
(2000) Social Identity and Self-Categorization Processes in Organizational Contexts. Academy of Management Review, 25 (1), 121–140. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Holmes, J., & Marra, M.
(2017) You’re a proper tradesman mate: Identity struggles and workplace transitions in New Zealand. In D. Van de Mieroop and S. Schnurr (Eds.), Identity struggles: Evidence from workplaces around the world (pp. 127–146). John Benjamins Publishing Company. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ibarra, H., & Barbulescu, R.
(2010) Identity as narrative: Prevalence, effectiveness, and consequences of narrative identity work in macro work role transitions. Academy of Management Review, 35 (1): 135–154. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Jain, P., & Krieger, J.
(2011) Moving beyond the language barrier: The communication strategies used by international medical graduates in intercultural medical encounters. Patient Education and Counselling, 84 (1): 98–104. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kalua, F.
(2009) Homi Bhabha’s third space and African identity. Journal of African Cultural Studies, 21 (1): 23–32. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Y.
(2001) Becoming intercultural: An integrative theory of communication and cross-cultural adaptation. Sage.Google Scholar
Lazzaro-Salazar, M. y Pujol-Cols, L.
(2020) Comunicación intercultural en instituciones públicas de la salud: Validación de la Escala de Conflicto Comunicacional en Organizaciones Interculturales (ECCOI). Lengua y Migración, 12(1), 123–148. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lazzaro-Salazar, M.
(2017) Ingroups and outgroups in complaints: Exploring politic behaviour in nurses’ discourse. Logos: Revista de Lingüística, Filosofía y Literatura, 27 (2), 319–333. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lazzaro-Salazar, M. y Pujol Cols, L.
(2017) Riesgos psicosociales e integración profesional de médicos extranjeros: Un estudio sobre el manejo del conflicto en la zona central de Chile. Revista Médica de Chile, 145 (10), 1300–1307. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lazzaro-Salazar, M.
(2013) Investigating Nurses’ Professional Identity Construction in Two Health Settings in New Zealand (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
Labov, W., & Waletzky, J.
(1967) Narrative analysis: Oral versions of personal experience. In J. Helm (Ed.), Essays on the verbal and visual arts (pp. 12–44). University of Washington Press.Google Scholar
Leiva, L.
(2015) El papel de los médicos extranjeros en consultorios (Santiago, Chile, pubd online 27 October 2020), accessed 19 Jan 2021.Google Scholar
Maguire, P., & Pitceathly, C.
(2002) Key communication skills and how to acquire them. British Medical Journal, 325 (7766), 697–700. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Manzi, C., Vignoles, V., & Regalia, C.
(2010) Accommodating a new identity: Possible selves, identity change and well-being across two life-transitions. European Journal of Social Psychology, 40 (6): 970–984. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Maynard, D. W., & Turowetz, J.
(2017) Doing diagnosis: Autism, interaction order, and the use of narrative in clinical talk. Social Psychology Quarterly, 80 (3), 254–275. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mildorf, J.
(2002) “Opening up a Can of Worms”: Physicians’ Narrative Construction of Knowledge about Domestic Violence. Narrative Inquiry, 12 (2), 233–260. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Norrick, N.
(2013) Narratives of Vicarious Experience in Conversation, Language in Society, 42 (4), 385–406. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Padilla, A., & Perez, W.
(2003) Acculturation, social identity, and social cognition: A new perspective. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 25 1, 35–55. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pennycook, A.
(2004) Performativity and language studies. Critical Inquiry in Language Studies, 1 1, 1–19. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pratt, M., Rockmann, K., & Kaufmann, J.
(2006) Constructing professional identity: The role of work and identity learning cycles in the customization of identity among medical residents. Academy of Management Journal, 49 (2), 235–262. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Preece, A.
(1987) The range of narrative forms conversationally produced by young children. Journal of Child Language, 14 1, 353–373. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Prince, G.
(1983) Narrative pragmatics, message, and point. Poetics, 12 (6), 527–536. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Rubinstein, R.
(1995) Narratives of elder parental death: A structural and cultural analysis. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 9 (2), 257–276. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Shuval, J.
(2000) The reconstruction of professional identity among immigrant physicians in three societies. Journal of Immigrant Health, 2 (4), 191–202. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sowinska, A., & Sokol, M.
(2018) “Luckily, she’s alive”: Narratives of vicarious experience told by Polish doctors. Journal of Pragmatics, 152 1, 76–88. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Srivastava, P., & Hopwood, N.
(2009) A practical iterative framework for qualitative data analysis. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 8 (1), 76–84. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Stagi, L.
(2015) Crossing the symbolic boundaries: parkour, gender and urban spaces in Genoa. Modern Italy, 20 (3), 295–305. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Stanley, P., & Hurst, M.
(2011) Narrative palliative care: a method for building empathy. Journal of Social Work in End-of-Life & Palliative Care, 7 (1), 39–55. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sussman, N.
(2000) The dynamic nature of cultural identity throughout cultural transitions: Why home is not so sweet. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 4 1, 355–373. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sveningsson, S., & Alvesson, M.
(2003) Managing managerial identities: Organizational fragmentation, discourse and identity struggle. Human Relations, 56 (4), 1163–1193. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Tajfel, H.
(1981) Human groups and social categories: Studies in social psychology. CUP Archive.Google Scholar
Trew, J.
(2007) Negotiating identity and belonging: Migration narratives of Protestants from Northern Ireland. Immigrants & Minorities, 25 (1), 22–48. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Van Maanen, J.
(1998) Identity work: Notes on the personal identity of police officers. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Academy of Management. San Diego, United States.
Vygotsky, L.
(1978) Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Wen Li, W., Hodgetts, D., & Ho, E.
(2010) Gardens, transitions and identity reconstruction among older Chinese immigrants to New Zealand. Journal of Health Psychology, 15 (5), 786–796. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wu, Z. Z., Zayts, O., Fortune, Z.
fc). “You’re not gonna admit to failure”: The Discourse of Mental Health Stigma in the Workplace. Journal of Sociolinguistics.
Yates, L.
(2015) Intercultural communication and the transnational: Managing impressions at work. Multilingua, 34 (6), 773–95. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zayts, O., & Norrick, N. R.
(2020) Narratives of Vicarious Experience in Professional and Workplace contexts: Introduction to the special issue. Journal of Pragmatics, 155 1, 64–69. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zayts, O., & Lazzaro-Salazar, M.
(2020) Healthcare communication in multicultural contexts: Exploring professional mobility. In Zsófia Demjén (Ed.), Applying Linguistics in Illness and Healthcare Contexts (pp. 299–325). London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
(2017) Making sense of transitions: Identity construction of migrant doctors in Chile and Hong Kong. Presented in 7th International Conference on Applied Linguistics and Professional Practice (ALAPP) , Ghent, Belgium, 21–23 November.
Zhao, X., & Mao, Y.
(2021) Trust me, I am a doctor: discourse of trustworthiness by Chinese doctors in online medical consultation. Health Communication, 36 (3), 372–380. CrossrefGoogle Scholar