Article published in:
Narrative Inquiry
Vol. 24:2 (2014) ► pp. 200–217

Atrocity stories and triumph stories

Using couple narratives to evaluate same-sex marriage and civil partnership

| University of Kent
This paper investigates conflicting narratives available to lesbian and gay couples as a result of marriage and civil partnership. Whereas marginalisation may have made stories of exclusion particularly resonant for same-sex couples, marriage and civil partnership offer scope for new stories around inclusion and equality. Drawing on empirical research with married and civil partner same-sex couples in the UK, US and Canada, the paper contrasts couples’ atrocity stories with new stories about acceptance and inclusion. The paper argues that these new stories should be seen as triumph stories that point towards a tangible impact arising from marriage equality and civil partnership. However, the presence of atrocity stories alongside these triumph stories provides evidence of a more limited policy impact. In conclusion, the paper highlights the relevance of atrocity stories in an emerging area of public policy, as well as the likelihood of triumph stories being relevant in other contexts.
Keywords: same-sex marriage, civil partnership, comparative research, LGB studies, atrocity stories
Published online: 24 November 2014
https://doi.org/10.1075/ni.24.2.02tho
References
Alderson, K.G
(2006) A phenomenological investigation of same-sex marriage. Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality, 13(2), 107–122.Google Scholar
Berger, J., & Quinney, R
(2005) The narrative turn in social inquiry. In J. Berger & R. Quinney (Eds.), Storytelling sociology: narrative as social inquiry (pp. 1–12). London: Lynne Reinner Publishers.Google Scholar
Carter, M
(2010) Telling tales: ‘Atrocity’ stories and the patient experience. Nursing Management, 16(9), 28–31. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Coffey, A., & Atkinson, P
(1996) Making sense of qualitative data: Complementary research strategies. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Delamont, S., & Atkinson, P
(2014) Narratives and accounts: Their collection and analysis. International Perspectives on Higher Education Research, 101, 43–61. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Department of culture, media and sport
(2014) Civil partnership review (England and Wales) - Report on conclusions. Retrieved from https://​www​.gov​.uk​/government​/uploads​/system​/uploads​/attachment​_data​/file​/324174​/Civil​_Partnership​_Review​_Report​_PDF​.pdf.
Department of trade and industry
(2004) Final regulatory impact assessment: Civil partnership act, 2004. London: The Stationery Office.Google Scholar
Dingwall, R
(1977) ‘Atrocity stories’ and professional relationships. Sociology of Work and Occupations, 4(4), 371–396. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
French, M
(1992) Loves, sexualities and marriages: Strategies and adjustments. In K. Plummer (Ed.), Modern homosexualities: Fragments of lesbian and gay experience (pp. 87–98). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Goffman, E
(1963) Stigma. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
Heaphy, B., Smart, C., & Einarsdottir, A
(2012) Same-sex marriage. London: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Hunter, J.D
(1992) Culture wars: The struggle to define America. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Jowett, A
(2013) ‘But if you legalise same-sex marriage…’: Arguments against marriage equality in the British press. Feminism and Psychology, 24(1), 37–55. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kertzner, R.M
(2012) A mental health research perspective on marital rights and civil marriage for lesbians and gay men. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Mental Health, 161, 36–145. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Koski, J.P
(2014) ‘I’m just a walking eating disorder:’ The mobilisation and construction of a collective illness identity in eating disorder support groups. Sociology of Health & Illness, 361, 75–90. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lannutti, P.J
(2011) Security, recognition and misgivings: Exploring older same-sex couples’ experiences of legally recognized same-sex marriage. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 28(1), 64–82. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2005) For better or worse: Exploring the meanings of same-sex marriage within the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered community. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 22(1), 5–18. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Leckey, R
(2013) Marriage and the data on same-sex couples. Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 35(2), 179–191. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Maisel, N.C., & Fingerhut, A.W
(2011) California’s ban on same-sex marriage: The campaign and its effects on gay, lesbian, and bisexual individuals. Journal of Social Issues, 67(2), 242–263. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mitchell, M., Dickens, S., & O’Connor, W
(2009) Same-sex couples and the impact of legislative changes. London: National Centre for Social Research.Google Scholar
Murray, C
(2010) Conceptualizing young people’s strategies of resistance to offending as ‘active resilience’. British Journal of Social Work, 40(1), 115–132. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Natale, A.P., & Miller-Cribbs, J.E
(2012) Same-sex marriage policy: Advancing social, political, and economic justice. Journal of GLBT Family Studies, 81, 155–172. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
New York Times
(2014) Same-sex marriage, civil unions, and domestic partnerships. Retrieved from http://​topics​.nytimes​.com​/top​/reference​/timestopics​/subjects​/s​/same​_sex​_marriage​/index​.html
Ould, P., & Whitlow, C.J
(2011) Same-sex marriage and context-specific kinship terms. Journal of Homosexuality, 58(8), 1085–1109. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Plummer, K
(1995) Telling sexual stories: Power, change and social worlds. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Rayside, D
(2008) Queer inclusions, continental divisions: Public recognition of sexual diversity in Canada and the United States. London: University of Toronto Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Riessman, C
(1993) Narrative analysis. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Roth, J.A
(1963) Timetables: Structuring the passage of time in hospital treatment and other careers. Indianapolis: Bobs-Merrill.Google Scholar
Shulman, J.L., Gotta, G., & Green, R.J
2012 Will marriage matter? Effects of marriage anticipated by same-sex couples. Journal of Family Issues, 33(2), 158–181. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Smart, C
(2007) Same sex couples and marriage: Negotiating relational landscapes with families and friends. The Sociological Review, 55(4), 671–686. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Smart, C., Mason, J., & Shipman, B
(2006) Gay and lesbian ‘marriage’: An exploration of the meanings and significance of legitimising same-sex relationships. Manchester: Morgan Centre for the Study of Relationships and Personal Life/Manchester University.Google Scholar
Solomon, S.E., Rothblum, E.D., & Balsam, K.F
(2004) Pioneers in partnership: Lesbian and gay male couples in civil unions compared with those not in civil unions and married heterosexual siblings. Journal of Family Psychology, 18(2), 275–286. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Stimson, G. & Webb,. B
(1975) Going to see the doctor: The consultation process in general practice. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Strauss, A., Schatzman, L., Bucher, R., Erlich, D., & Sabshin, M
(1964) Psychiatric ideologies and institutions. London: Collier-Macmillan.Google Scholar
Warren, C.A.B
(2002) Qualitative interviewing. In J.F. Gubrium, & J.A. Holstein, (Eds.), Handbook of interview research (pp. 83–101). London: Sage.Google Scholar
Washer, P
(2010) Emerging infectious diseases and society. Basingstoke: Palgrave. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Webb, B., & Stimpson, G
(1976) People’s accounts of medical encounters. In M. Wadsworth & D. Robinson (Eds.), Studies in everyday medical life (pp. 108–122). London: Martin Robertson & Co. Ltd.Google Scholar
Webb, S.N., & Chonody, J
(2013) Heterosexual attitudes toward aame-sex marriage: The influence of attitudes toward same-sex parenting. Journal of GLBT Family Studies, 10(4), 404–421. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Weeks, J
(2007) The world we have won: The remaking of erotic and intimate life. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Cited by

Cited by 7 other publications

Bartoș, Sebastian E. & Darren Langdridge
2019. LGBQ resilience: a thematic meta-synthesis of qualitative research. Psychology & Sexuality 10:3 ► pp. 234 ff. Crossref logo
Carter, Julia
2017. Why Marry? The Role of Tradition in Women's Marital Aspirations. Sociological Research Online 22:1 ► pp. 1 ff. Crossref logo
Drabble, Laurie A., Amy A. Mericle, Cat Munroe, Angie R. Wootton, Karen F. Trocki & Tonda L. Hughes
2021. Examining Perceived Effects of Same-Sex Marriage Legalization Among Sexual Minority Women: Identifying Demographic Differences and Factors Related to Alcohol Use Disorder, Depression, and Self-Perceived Health. Sexuality Research and Social Policy Crossref logo
Drabble, Laurie A., Angie R. Wootton, Cindy B. Veldhuis, Ellen D. B. Riggle, Sharon S. Rostosky, Pamela J. Lannutti, Kimberly F. Balsam, Tonda L. Hughes & Peter A. Newman
2021. Perceived psychosocial impacts of legalized same-sex marriage: A scoping review of sexual minority adults’ experiences. PLOS ONE 16:5 ► pp. e0249125 ff. Crossref logo
Nelson-Becker, Holly & Michael Thomas
2020. Religious/Spiritual Struggles and Spiritual Resilience in Marginalised Older Adults. Religions 11:9 ► pp. 431 ff. Crossref logo
Rostosky, Sharon S., Ellen D. B. Riggle, Esther D. Rothblum & Kimberly F. Balsam
2016. Same-Sex Couples’ Decisions and Experiences of Marriage in the Context of Minority Stress: Interviews From a Population-Based Longitudinal Study. Journal of Homosexuality 63:8 ► pp. 1019 ff. Crossref logo
Rostosky, Sharon Scales & Ellen DB Riggle
2017. Same-sex relationships and minority stress. Current Opinion in Psychology 13 ► pp. 29 ff. Crossref logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 10 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.