Chapter 1
The invention of violence
This chapter presents and analyzes ethnographic data collected in Buenos Aires among soccer fans that are taken to behave in violent ways. The analysis addresses the relationship between fans and the police force. Using the theoretical framework proposed by Roy Wagner in The Invention of Culture, this text suggests that, with their single-minded focus on order and control, the police project the image of unruliness and resistance to police authority upon the soccer fans, which, in turn, induces the police to neurotically escalate and use violence. The fans, on the other hand, focus on heroic deeds and “protagonism” as part of their processes of individualization, and see the police force as an impediment to achieving their goals, which then leads them to act more energetically – hysterically – in their usual fandom activities. Neurosis and hysteria are used in specific ways, as shall be defined in the text.
Article outline
- Introduction
- Entry into the field
- The invention of hooliganism
- Neurotics and hysterics
- Fans and police officers in Buenos Aires
- The invention of violence
-
Notes
-
References
References (66)
References
Alabarces, Pablo, and Maria Graciela Rodriguez. 1996. Cuestión de pelotas: futbol, deporte, sociedad, cultura [A Matter of Balls: Soccer, Spots, Society, and Culture]. Cap. Federal, Argentina: Atuel.
Alabarces, Pablo, and Maria Graciela Rodriguez. 1998. “Fútbol y Patria: la crisis de la representación de lo nacional en el fútbol argentino” [Soccer and Nation: the Crisis of the National Representation in Argentinian Soccer]. Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportes 3 (10), accessed 7 February 2017, [URL]
Alabarces, Pablo et al. 2000. “Aguante y represión. Fútbol, violencia y política en la Argentina [Strenght and Repression. Soccer, Violence, and Politics in Argentina]”. In Peligro de gol‚ Estudios sobre deporte y sociedad en América Latina [Risk of Goal, Studies in Sports and Society on Latin America], ed. by Pablo Alabarces, 211–230. Buenos Aires: Grupos de Trabajo de CLACSO, Deporte y Sociedad.
Alabarces, Pablo. 1992. Fútbol y Cultura. Deporte, política, vida cotidiana [Soccer and Culture. Sport, Politics, Everyday Life]. Buenos Aires: Ediciones Cursos Universitarios.
Archetti, Eduardo P. 1985. Fútbol y ethos [Soccer and Ethos]. Buenos Aires: FLACSO.
Archetti, Eduardo P. 1994. “Masculinity and Football: the Formation of National Identity in Argentina.” In Game without frontiers: football, identity and modernity, ed. by Richard Giulianotti, and John Williams, 225–243. Aldershot: Arena.
Archetti, Eduardo P. 1999. Masculinities: Football, Polo and the Tango in Argentina. Oxford: Berg.
Armstrong, Gary. 1994. “False Leeds: The Construction of Hooligan Confrontations.” In Game without Frontiers: Football, Identity and Modernity, ed. by Richard Giulianotti, and John Williams, 299–326. Aldershot: Arena.
Armstrong, Gary. 2003. Football Hooligans: Knowing the Score. London: Berg.
Armstrong, Gary, and Malcom Young. 1997. “Legislators and Interpreters: The Law and ‘Football Hooliganism’”. In Entering the Field: New Perspectives on World Football, ed. by Gary Armstrong, and Richard Giulianotti, 175–192. Oxford: Berg Publishers.
Bamford, Sandra, Joel Robbins, Justin Shaffner, and James Weiner (eds.). 2008. “Roy Wagner: Symbolic Anthropology and the Fate of the New Melanesian Ethnography.” Session at the Conference for the European Society for Oceanists, Verona, July 10–12, 2008.
Bateson, Gregory. 2000. Steps to an Ecology of Mind. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1977. Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 

Briggs, Charles L. 2005. “Communicability, Racial Discourse, and Disease.” Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 269–91 

Briggs, Charles L. 2011. “On Virtual Epidemics and the Mediatization of Public Health.” Language and Communication 31: 217–228. 

Burstyn, Varda. 1999. The Rites of Men: Manhood, Politics, and the Culture of Sport. Toronto; Buffalo, NY: University of Toronto Press. 

Cardoso, Vânia Zikán (ed.). 2010. “Number 1: Thematic Section: Seminary of Fox.” Ilha Revista de Antropologia 12 (1).
Carnibella et al. 1996. Football violence in Europe. Oxford: The Social Issues Research Centre.
Daniel, E. Valentine. 1998. “The Limits of Culture.” In In Near Ruins: Cultural Theory at the End of the Century, ed. by Nicholas B. Dirks, 67–91. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Echeverría, Esteban. 1874. “El Matadero [The Slaughterhouse]”. In Obras Completas de D. Esteban Echeverría [Complete Works of D. Esteban Echeverría], ed. by Juan María Gutiérrez, 1870–1874. Buenos Aires: Carlos Casavalle Editor.
Galeano, Eduardo. 1968. Su majestad el fútbol. Montevideo: Arca.
Galeano, Eduardo. 1995. Fútbol a sol y sombra. Buenos Aires: Catálogos.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2005a. “‘Amigos y no tan amigos.’ Los integrantes de una hinchada de fútbol y sus relaciones personales. [“Friends and not so Much”: Members of a Soccer Fan Group and their Personal Relationships].” Cuadernos del IDES 7: 3–33.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2005b. “Lomo de macho. Cuerpo, masculinidad y violencia de un grupo de simpatizantes del fútbol. [Macho’s Loin. Body, Masculinity, and Violence in a Group of Soccer Supporters].” Cuadernos de Antropología Social 22: 201–216.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2006. “‘Acá es así’. Hinchadas de fútbol, violencia y territorios [“This is How Things are Here”. Soccer Fan Groups, Violence, and Territories].” avá 9: 93–107.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2007. “Entre ‘machos’ y ‘putos’: estilos masculinos y prácticas violentas de una hinchada de fútbol. [Between ‘Machos’ and “Sluts’: Masculine Styles and Violent Practices in a Group of Soccer Fans].” Esporte e Sociedade 2 (4), accessed February 7, 2017, [URL].
Garriga Zucal, José. 2009. “Violencia e identidad: las hinchadas de futbol en la Argentina. [Violence and Identity: the Soccer Fan Groups in Argentina].” Urvio, Revista Latinoamericana de Seguridad Ciudadana 8: 101–016.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2010. “Violencia: un concepto difícil de asir. [Violence: a Difficult Concept to Grasp].” Antropolitica 29: 225–241.
Garriga Zucal, José. 2012. “‘Un té de Pirelli’ – Los sentidos de la violencia para la policía de la provincia de Buenos Aires. [“A Tea of Pirelli” – The Meanings of Violence to the Police of the Province of Buenos Aires]” Questión 1 (33): 46–58.
Gil, Gastón Julián. 1997. “Rebotes de identidad. El basquet en la cultura urbana del interior (Mar del Plata, Argentina). El nacimiento de las rivalidades. [Rebounds of Identity. Basketball in the Urban Culture of the Interior (Mar del Plata, Argentina). The Birth of Rivalries].” Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportes 2 (6), accessed February 7, 2017, [URL]
Gil, Gastón Julián. 1998. “El cuerpo popular en los rituales deportivos. [The Popular Body in Sportive Rituals].” Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportes 3 (10), accessed February 7, 2017, [URL]
Gil, Gastón Julián. 2004. “‘Violencia, Irracionalidade y Estados Alterados’. Apuntes etnográficos sobre el consumo de alcohol y drogas entre hinchas argentinos. [‘Violence, Irrationality, and Altered States’. Etnographic Notes on the Consuption of Alcohol and Drugs Among Argentinian Soccer Fans].” Ilha 6 (1/2): 29–48.
Gil, Gastón Julián. 2006. “‘Te sigo a todas partes’. Pasión y aguante en una hinchada de fútbol de un club del interior [‘I Follow You Everywhere’. Passion and Strenght in a Fan Group of a Soccer Club of the Interior].” Intersecciones en Antropología 7: 333–348.
Gil, Gastón Julián. 2008a. “La pasión según Aldosivi. El ‘otro’ y los combates por la identidad. [Título]” Horizontes Antropológicos 14 (30): 137–164. 

Gil, Gastón Julián. 2008b. “Criminalización, arbitrariedad y doble militancia. La policía y la violencia en el fútbol argentino [Criminalization, Arbitrarity, and Double Militancy. Police and Violence in Argentinian Soccer].” Revista de Estudios Sociales 31: 132–145.
Giulianotti, Richard, and John Williams. 1994. Game without Frontiers: Football, Identity and Modernity. Aldershot: Arena.
Graeber, David. 2006. Beyond Power/Knowledge: An Exploration of the Relation of Power, Ignorance and Stupidity. Malinowski Lecture, London School of Economics and Political Science, Thursday 25 May 2006.
Graeber, David. 2007. “On the Phenomenology of Giant Puppets: Broken Windows, Imaginary Jars of Urine, and the Cosmological Role of the Police in American Culture.” In Possibilities: Essays on Hierarchy, Rebellion, and Desire, 375–418. Edinburgh: A K Press.
Harrington, John. 1968. Soccer Hooliganism. Bristol: John Wright.
Kelly, William W. 2009. “Samurai Baseball: The Vicissitudes of a National Sporting Style.” The International Journal of the History of Sport 26 (3): 429–441. 

Maradona, Diego. 2000. Yo Soy El Diego. Buenos Aires: Planeta.
Martinez, Reinaldo. 1999. “La violencia del fútbol. [Violence in Soccer]” In Jugados: critica a la patria deportista, ed. by Morales, Victor Hugo et al. Buenos Aires: Eudeba.
Misse, Michel. 2008. “Dizer a violência [To Say the Violence].” Revista Katálysis 11 (2):165–166. 

Moorhouse, Herbert F. 1984. “Professional Football and Working Class Culture: English Theories and Scottish Evidence.” Sociological Review 32 (2):285–315. 

Moorhouse, Herbert F. 1991. “On the Periphery: Scotland, Scottish Football and the New Europe.” In British Football and Social Change: Getting into Europe, ed. by John Williams and Stephen Wagg, 201–219. Leicester: Leicester University Press.
Moreira, Maria Verónica. 2006. Una mujer en campo masculino y la identificación de género en el proceso de producción del conocimiento antropológico [A Woman in a Masculine Field and Gender Identification in the Process of Production of Anthropological Knowledge]. Paper presented at Seminário Internacional Fazendo Gênero 7, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, 28 a 30 de agosto de 2006.
Moreira, Maria Verónica. 2007. “Etnografía sobre el honor y la violencia de una hinchada de fútbol en Argentina. [Ethnography on Honor and Violence of a Soccer Fan Group in Argentina].” Revista Austral de Ciencias Sociales 13:5–20. 

Moreira, Maria Verónica. 2008. “‘Buenos luchadores y grandes hombres’: poder y política de una hinchada de fútbol en Argentina [Good Fighters and Great Men: Power and Politics in a Soccer Fan Group in Argentina].” Questión, Revista Especializada en Periodismo y Comunicación 1 (17): 1–10.
Murray, David, and Joel Robbins (eds.). 2002. “Reinventing the Invention of Culture.” Special issue of The International Journal of Cultural and Social Practice 46 (1).
Núcleo de Antropologia Simétrica (NAnSi). 2011. “
A academia e a floresta: visões xamânicas
. [The Academy and the Forest: Xamanic Visions].” Conference in honor of Davi Kopenawa Yanomami, Mauricio Ye’kuana and Roy Wagner. Museu Nacional, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, August 12 and 15, 2011.
Piglia, Ricardo. 1993. “Echeverría y el lugar de la ficción. [Echeverría and the Location of Fiction].” In La Argentina en Pedazos. Buenos Aires: Ediciones de la Urraca, accessed February 7, 2017, [URL]
Romero, Amilcar. 1986. Muerte en la cancha (1958–1985) [Death in the Soccer Field (1958–1985)]. Buenos Aires: Editorial Nueva América.
Salvo, Andrés Recasens. 1999. Las Barras Bravas: estudio antropológico [The ‘Barras Bravas’: An Anthropological Study]. Santiago: Bravo y Allende Editores / Universidad de Chile.
Sebreli, Juan José. 1981. Futbol y masas [Soccer and Crowds]. Buenos Aires: Editorial Galerna.
Sirvent, Maria Teresa. 1999. Cultura popular y participación social. Una investigación en el barrio de Mataderos, Buenos Aires [Popular Culture and Social Participation. A Research in the Neighborhood of Mataderos, Buenos Aires]. Buenos Aires: Miño y Dávila Editores.
Taddei, Renzo. 2001. Soccer Passion and Violence in Argentina. Ethnographical Notes on Soccer Fandom in Buenos Aires. Paper presented at the Anthropology Programs Colloquium, Teachers College, Columbia University, Fall 2001.
Taddei, Renzo. 2002. “Notas sobre la economía política de categorías y denominaciones en el fútbol argentino [Notes on the Political Economy of Categories and Denominations in Argentinian Soccer].” Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportes 8 (55), accessed February 7, 2017, [URL]
Taddei, Renzo. 2009. “Notes on the Semiotic Phenomenology of Social Discrimination.” Galáxia 17: 147–159.
Taddei, Renzo. 2012. Forecasting Not To See The Future: Comments On The Performatic Dimensions of Climate Forecasting. Paper presented at the 12th Biennial Conference of the European Association of Social Anthropologists, Nanterre, France, July 12, 2012.
Taussig, Michael. 1987. Shamanism, Colonialism and the Wild Man. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 

Taylor, Ian 1969. “Hooligans: Soccers resistance movement.” New Society 14 (358): 204–205.
Vargas, Walter. 1999. “Fútbol: opiniones & merodeos [Soccer: Opinions and Maraudings].” In Jugados: crítica a la patria deportista, ed. by Victor Hugo Morales. Buenos Aires: Eudeba.
Veiga, Gustavo. 1998. Donde manda la patota: barrabravas, poder y política [Where the Gang Rules: ‘Barrabravas”, Power, and Politics]. Buenos Aires: Agora.
Viveiros de Castro, Eduardo. 2002. “Perspectivismo e multinaturalismo na América indígena [Perspectivism and Multinaturalism in Indigenous America].” In A Inconstância da Alma Selvagem, 345–399. São Paulo: Cosac Naify.
Wagner, Roy. 1981 [1975]. The Invention of Culture. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Whiting, Robert. 2006. “The Samurai Way of Baseball and the National Character Debate.” Studies on Asia 3 (2):104–122.