Chapter 6
Cancel Culture and influencers
The Hilaria Baldwin case
The cancellation of Hilaria Baldwin, amid accusations of deception (regarding claims that she was a
Spanish woman and Spanish was her native language) and Cultural Appropriation (CAPP), was a complex case, involving
language ideologies, authenticity, and the racialization undergone by the Spanish language and related identities in the US, exacerbated by Cancel Culture (CC).
While CC has been widely discussed in non-academic literature, recent academic scholarship on the topic largely takes
a macro approach. This chapter provides a less frequent examination of cancellation processes at the micro level,
analyzing user-generated posts in related YouTube videos. Drawing on discursive pragmatics and Corpus Assisted
Discourse Studies, it argues that Hilaria Baldwin’s case is deeply connected to perceptions of Spanish/Latino/Hispanic
identity in the US. Despite dissent on CAPP, Hilaria’s dishonesty about her background triggered her cancellation,
reenforcing claims about the fundamental link between perceived immoral behavior and cancellation events as well as
the high expectations regarding authenticity in influencers’ self-presentation.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Background to Hilaria Baldwin’s cancellation
- 3.Understanding CC
- 3.1A discursive pragmatic approach to CC and cancellation
- 3.1.1Macro level
- 3.1.2Meso level
- 3.1.3Micro level
- 4.Triggers of Hilaria’s cancellation
- 4.1Cultural Appropriation (CAPP): Issues of race/racialization of identities and language
- 4.2Lying and authenticity
- 5.Methodology
- 5.1Data sampling and selection
- 5.2Theoretical framework and procedure of analysis
- 6.Results and discussion
- 6.1Corpus-assisted analysis: Quantitative analysis
- 6.2Qualitative analysis
- 6.2.1Cultural exploitation or cultural exchange?
- 6.2.2Reasons for cancellation
- 6.Conclusion
-
Notes
-
References