On perception as the basis for object concepts
A critical analysis
Nicolás Alessandroni | Universidad Autónoma de Madrid , Spain
Cintia Rodríguez | Universidad Autónoma de Madrid , Spain
Within cognitive and developmental psychology, it is commonly argued that perception is the basis for object concepts.
According to this view, sensory experiences would translate into concepts thanks to the recognition, correlation and integration of physical
attributes. Once attributes are integrated into general patterns, subjects would become able to parse objects into categories. In this
article, we critically review the three epistemological perspectives according to which it can be claimed that object concepts depend on
perception: state non-conceptualism, content non-conceptualism, and content conceptualism. We show that
the three perspectives have problems that make perception inadequate as a conceptual basis. We suggest that the inquiry about the origin and
development of object concepts can benefit from a pragmatic perspective that considers objects’ cultural functions as a
conceptual foundation. We address this possibility from the theoretical framework of the pragmatics of the object,
considering the importance of objects’ functional permanence.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Object concepts as a by-product of perception
- 3.The relationship between perceptions and concepts: Three options, three problem sets
- 3.1State non-conceptualism and its problems
- 3.1.1Perceptual constancy is not a natural phenomenon
- 3.1.2Perceptual constancy is conceptual
- 3.1.3The perception of qualities involves different developmental achievements
- 3.2Content non-conceptualism and its problems
- 3.2.1Non-conceptual perceptions cannot justify beliefs: A semantic problem
- 3.2.2Concepts do not have contact with the real world: A problem of reference
- 3.3Conceptualism and its problems
- 3.3.1Demonstrative concepts are a chimaera
- 3.3.2Explanatory circularity
- 3.3.3Misperception, culture and re-identification
- 3.3.4Content overlapping and animal cognition
- 3.3.5Inflexible concepts
- 3.3.6Individual concepts and explanatory solipsism
- 3.1State non-conceptualism and its problems
- 4.Perception in its labyrinth: A pragmatic and functional way out
- 4.1Perception is not contemplation
- 4.2The pragmatics of the object: Cognitive development from a pragmatic, functional, and cultural perspective
- 5.Conclusions
- Declaration of interest statement
- Notes
-
References
Published online: 12 February 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/pc.19027.ale
https://doi.org/10.1075/pc.19027.ale
References
Alessandroni, Nicolás
Alessandroni, Nicolás & Cintia Rodríguez
Alessandroni, Nicolás, Ana Moreno-Núñez, Cintia Rodríguez & María Jesús Del Olmo
Alvarez, George A. & Steven L. Franconeri
Archer, James
Aristotle. trans
Arnold, Jeanne E., Anthony P. Graesch, Enzo Ragazzini & Elinor Ochs
Babska, Zofia
Bambach, Sven, Linda B. Smith, David J. Crandall & Chen Yu
Barsalou, Lawrence W., Léo Dutriaux & Christoph Scheepers
Barsalou, Lawrence W., Steven Sloman & Sergio Chaigneau
Bomba, Paul C. & Einar R. Siqueland
Bruner, Jerome S., Jacqueline J. Goodnow & George A. Austin
Burns, Barbara
Byers, Patrick
Byrne, Alex
Cabell, Kenneth R. & Jaan Valsiner
Cahen, Arnon & Michela C. Tacca
Casasola, Marianella & Yeojin A. Ahn
Chaigneau, Sergio & Lawrence W. Barsalou
Chen, Quanjing, Frank E. Garcea & Bradford Z. Mahon
Chiou, Rocco, Paul F. Sowman, Andrew C. Etchell & Anina N. Rich
Chuard, Philippe
Clark, Eve V.
Cohen, Jonathan
Cohen, Leslie B. & Mark S. Strauss
Cole, Michael
Cosmides, Leda & John Tooby
Costall, Alan & Ole Dreier
D’Alfonso, Simon
2018 McDowell and misperception. Unpublished manuscript. http://simondalfonso.id.au/documents/philosophy/McDowell.pdf
Efron, Robert
Eimas, Peter D. & Paul C. Quinn
Fagan, Joseph F.
Fechner, Gustav T.
Firestone, Chaz & Brian J. Scholl
Fleming, Roland W.
Galpérine, Piotr
Gärdenfors, Peter
Gelaes, Sabine & Jean-Pierre Thibaut
Gentner, Dedre
Gibson, James J.
Gleason, Tracy R., Kate E. Fiske & Ruth K. Chan
Goldstone, Robert L. & Andrew T. Hendrickson
Gori, Monica
Granrud, Carl E.
Gruber, Craig W., Matthew G. Clark, Sven Hroar Klempe & Jaan Valsiner
Heck, Richard. G.
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Hering, Ewald
Horst, Jessica S., Lisa M. Oakes & Kelly L. Madole
Huttenlocher, Janellen, Sean Duffy & Susan Levine
Jacobson, Hilla & Hilary Putnam
Jahoda, Gustav & Ioan M. Lewis
Kagan, Jerome
Keil, Frank C.
Kelly, Sean D.
Kemler Nelson, Deborah G., Rachel Russell, Nell Duke & Kate Jones
Kimura, Atsushi, Yuji Wada, Jiale Yang, Yumiko Otsuka, Ippeita Dan, Tomohiro Masuda, So Kanazawa & Masami K. Yamaguchi
Köhler, Wolfgang
Koopman, Sarah E., Bradford Z. Mahon & Jessica F. Cantlon
Krnel, Dušan & Darija Skubic
Lécuyer, Roger & Katia Rovira
Leóntiev, Alekséi N. & Aleksandr R. Luria
Luria, Aleksandr R.
MacVean, Mary
2014, March 21. For many people, gathering possessions is just the stuff of life. Los Angeles Times. http://articles.latimes.com/2014/mar/21/health/la-he-keeping-stuff-20140322
Maddy, Penelope
Malafouris, Lambros
Malt, Barbara C., Silvia P. Genari, Mutsumi Imai, Eef Ameel, Noburo Saji & Asifa Majid
Mandler, Jean M.
Mandler, Jean M., Patricia J. Bauer & Laraine McDonough
Mandler, Jean M., Robyn Fivush & J. Steven Reznick
Mandler, Jean M. & Laraine McDonough
Mandler, Jean M. & Cristóbal Pagán Cánovas
Martí, Eduardo
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice
Mervis, Carolyn B. & Eleanor Rosch
Miceli, Gabriele, Erin Fouch, Rita Capasso, Jennifer R. Shelton, Francesco Tomaiuolo & Alfonso Caramazza
Moro, Christiane & Cintia Rodríguez
Morvan, Pierre le
Nelson, Katherine
Nudds, Matthew
Oakes, Lisa M.
Olkkonen, Maria, Thorsten Hansen & Karl R. Gegenfurtner
Olkkonen, Maria, Christoph Witzel, Thorsten Hansen & Karl R. Gegenfurtner
Palacios, Pedro & Cintia Rodríguez
Palacios, Pedro, Cintia Rodríguez & Cecilia Méndez-Sánchez
Palmer, Stephen E.
Pauen, Sabina, Träuble Birgit, Stefanie Hoehl & Sabrina Bechtel
Peacocke, Christopher
Pérez, Diana I., Silvia Español, Liza Skidelsky & Ricardo A. Minervino
Piaget, Jean
Prinz, Jesse J.
Quine, Willard van O.
Quinn, Paul C. & Mark H. Johnson
Quinn, Paul C., Peter D. Eimas & Stacey L. Rosenkrantz
Rakison, David H. & George E. Butterworth
Reichard, Suzanne, Marion Schneider & David Rapaport
Rettler, Bradley & Andrew M. Bailey
2017 Object. In Edward N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Stanford: Center for the Study of Language and Information, Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2017/entries/object/
Rodríguez, Cintia
Rodríguez, Cintia, Marisol Basilio, Karina Cárdenas, Silvia Cavalcante, Ana Moreno-Núñez, Pedro Palacios & Noemi Yuste
Rodríguez, Cintia, Julia Benassi, Luisa Estrada & Nicolás Alessandroni
Rodríguez, Cintia & Christiane Moro
Rodríguez, Cintia & Nora Scheuer
Rodríguez, Cintia, Pedro Palacios, Karina Cárdenas & Noemi Yuste
Ross, Brian H.
Rossmanith, Nicole & Vasudevi Reddy
Ruff, Holly A.
Russell, Terry, Ken Longden & Linda McGuigan
Säljö, Roger
Saussure, Ferdinand de
Schmidt, Eva
Schyns, Philippe G., Robert L. Goldstone & Jean-Pierre Thibaut
Sedivy, Sonia
Shams, Ladan, Yukiyasu Kamitani & Shinsuke Shimojo
Shanks, David R.
Sloutsky, Vladimir M.
Smith, Linda B., Sandra Street, Susan S. Jones & Karin H. James
Spitz, René A.
Stavans, Maayan & Renée Baillargeon
Susi, Tarja & Tom Ziemke
Thill, Serge & Katherine E. Twomey
Tomikawa, Sandra A. & David H. Dodd
Toribio, Josefa
Van Gulick, Ana & Michael Tarr
Varela, Francisco J., Evan Thompson & Eleanor Rosch
Vetter, Petra & Albert Newen
Vygotsky, Lev S.
Wallon, Henri & Gaby Ascoli
Welch, Livingston
Wilcox, Teresa & Marisa Biondi
Wisniewski, Edward J. & Douglas L. Medin
Witzel, Christoph & Karl R. Gegenfurtner
Witzel, Christoph, Maria Olkkonen & Karl R. Gegenfurtner
Wright, William K.
Yang, Jiale, So Kanazawa, Masami K. Yamaguchi & Ichiro Kuriki
Yang, Jiale, So Kanazawa, Masami K. Yamaguchi & Isamu Motoyoshi
Yang, Jiale, Yumiko Otsuka, So Kanazawa, Masami K. Yamaguchi & Isamu Motoyoshi
Young, Thomas
Younger, Barbara A.
Younger, Barbara A. & Dru D. Fearing
Zamudio, Alicia M. & José A. Castorina
Zaporozhets, Alexander V.
Zentall, Thomas R., Danielle M. Andrews & Jacob P. Case