Article published in:Writing and the Mind
Edited by David R. Olson and Marcelo Dascal †
[Pragmatics & Cognition 21:3] 2013
► pp. 484–504
Archaic lists, writing and mind
Theories of writing and mind have proposed that the uses of literacy give rise to a distinct repertoire of cognitive skills, attitudes, and concepts. This paper reconsiders the earliest lexical lists of the Ancient Near East as one type of evidence on writing and mind. Past and present conceptions of the lists are briefly reviewed. Early views cast the lists as reflecting a Sumerian mentality or a uniquely literate mode of thought, while recent accounts suggest they may simply be routine scribal exercises. A view from the philosophy of science, on which lists are considered a sub-type of ordering system, suggests a way of aligning a scribal practice account with aspects of earlier views by articulating the nature of list entries and the intentions of the list makers. On this account, the Ancient Near Eastern lists can be seen both as uniquely literate and as uniquely informative on the role of writing in mind.
Published online: 24 July 2015
Crüsemann, N., van Ess, M., Hilgert, M. and Salje, B
Englund, R.K. and H.J. Nissen
Goody, J. and Watt, I
Green, M.W., Nissen, H.J., with Damerow, P. and Englund, R.K
Humboldt, W. von
Mayr, E. and Bock, W.J
Margolis, E. and Laurence, S
2011 “Literacy, schooling, and the transmission of knowledge in early Mesopotamian culture”. In W.S. van Egmond and W.H. van Soldt (eds), Theory and Practice of Knowledge Transfer: Studies in School Education in the Ancient Near East and Beyond. Leiden: Nederlands Institute voor het Nabije Oosten, 39–58.
2013 “The Mesopotamian king lists: History in the making. Paper presented at the workshop “Ancient and modern perspectives on historiography in Mesopotamia.” Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, New York University, April.
Nissen, H.J., Damerow, P., and Englund R.K
Scribner, S. and Cole, M
van Egmond, W.S. and van Soldt, W.H
1997 Elementary Education at Nippur: The Lists of Trees and Wooden Objects. PhD dissertation, University of Groningen.
2011b “Domesticizing Babylonian Scribal Culture in Assyria: Transformation by Preservation”. In W.S. van Egmond and W.H. van Soldt (eds), Theory and Practice of Knowledge Transfer: Studies in School Education in the Ancient Near East and Beyond. Nederlands Institute voor het Nabije Oosten: Leiden, 11–24.
von Soden, W
2007 “Early Lexical Lists Revisited: Structures and Classification as a Mnemonic Device”. In L. Kogan, N. Koslova, S. Loesov, and S. Tischenko (eds), Language in the Ancient Near East. (Proceedings of the 53rd Rencontre Assyriologique Internationale Vol. 1, Part 1.) Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 285–310.
Watson, R. and Horowitz, W