Article published in:
Pragmatics
Vol. 30:3 (2020) ► pp. 326–350

Identity (self-)deconstruction in Chinese police’s civil conflict mediation

| Nanjing University
| Nanjing University
While recent pragmatic research on identity in discourse mainly focuses on ubiquitous construction of one’s own or others’ identity, inadequate attention has been directed to the frequently occurring deconstruction of self-constructed and other-assigned identities. Drawing on transcripts of recordings of 19 Chinese police officer-mediated interactions, this study examines what, how and why self-constructed and other-assigned identities of police officers are deconstructed. Qualitative analysis of the data shows that Chinese police officers’ self-constructed non-institutional identities were often deconstructed by disputants via negating their contextual appropriateness or their social or institutional rightness, whereas police officers also often deconstructed the institutional identities assigned to them by the disputants via negating the validity of the assigned institutional identity or the institutional relationship. It is argued that the cause of this identity deconstruction phenomenon is rooted in police officers’ identity dilemma arising from social changes regarding police work in China.
Keywords: institutional discourse, identity, pragmatic identity, identity deconstruction, mediation, Chinese police mediation
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Literature review
    • 2.1Previous research on identity deconstruction
    • 2.2Previous research on Chinese mediation
  • 3.Methodology
    • 3.1Research questions
    • 3.2Data collection
    • 3.3Data analysis
  • 4.Results of the study
    • 4.1Disputants’ deconstruction of police officers’ self-constructed non-institutional identities
      • 4.1.1By negating the appropriateness of the identities for the institutional setting
      • 4.1.2By negating the social rightness of the identities
    • 4.2Police officers’ deconstruction of identities assigned by the disputants
      • 4.2.1By negating the validity of the other-assigned institutional identity and clarifying a non-institutional identity or communicative goal
      • 4.2.2By negating the institutional relationship and claiming a non-institutional relationship
  • 5.Discussion
  • 6.Conclusion
  • Acknowledgements
  • References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC) 4.0 license.
Published online: 03 June 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/prag.19039.fen
References
Antaki, Charles, and Sue Widdicombe
1998 “Identity as an Achievement and as a Tool.” In Identities in Talk. ed. by Charles Antaki, and Sue Widdicombe, 1–15. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Benwell, Bethan, and Elizabeth Stokoe
2006 Discourse and Identity. Edinburgh UK: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Bercal, Thomas E.
1970 “Calls for Police Assistance: Consumer Demands for Governmental Service.” American Behavioral Sciences 13 (5): 681–690. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Black, Donald
1980 The Manners and Customs of the Police. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Bucholtz, Mary, and Kira Hall
2005 “Identity and Interaction: A Socio-cultural Linguistic Approach.” Discourse Studies 7 (4–5): 585–614. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Buerger, Michael E., Anthony J. Petrosino, and Carolyn Petrosino
1999 “Extending the Police Role: Implications of Police Mediation as a Problem- Solving Tool.” Police Quarterly 2 (2): 125–149. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Chan, Angela, Stephanie Schnurr, and Olga Zayts
2018 “Exploring Face, Identity and Relationship Management in Disagreements in Business Meetings in Hong Kong.” Journal of Politeness Research 14 (2): 233–260. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Chen, Rong, and Xinren Chen
2020 “Introduction.” East Asian Pragmatics 5 (1):1–8. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Chen, Xinren
2013 “语用身份：动态选择与话语建构 [Pragmatic Identity: Dynamic Choice and Discursive Construction].” Foreign Languages Research 41: 27–112.Google Scholar
2014 “语用学视角下的身份研究—关键问题与主要路径 [Current Research on Identity from the Pragmatic Perspective: Key Issues and Main Approaches].” Modern Foreign Languages 37 (5): 702–710.Google Scholar
2018 Pragmatic Identity: How to Do Things with Words of Identity. Beijing: Beijing Normal University Press.Google Scholar
2020 “Identity Work and Politeness Evaluation.” Journal of PLA University of Foreign Languages 43 (2): 1–10.Google Scholar
Cooper, Christopher
2001 “Mediation in Black and White: Mediation Center-Police Partnerships – A Dignified Police Response.” Mediation Quarterly 18 (3): 281–295. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Davies, Bethan L.
2018 “Evaluating Evaluations: What Different Types of Metapragmatic Behaviour Can Tell Us About Participants’ Understandings of the Moral Order.” Journal of Politeness Research 14 (1): 121–151. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
D’Cruz, Carolyn
2008 Identity Politics in Deconstruction: Calculating with the Incalculable. England, Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Limited.Google Scholar
Deaux, Kay, and Kathleen A. Ethier
1998 “Negotiating Social Identity.” In Prejudice: The Target’s Perspective, ed. by Janet K. Swim, and Charles Stangor, 301–323. San Diego: Academic Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
De Fina, Anna, Deborah Schiffrin, and Michael Bamberg
2006 Discourse and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Deng, Yiheng, Kaibin Xu, Xiaoqiu Fu, and Sang Ma
2013 “Mediating Conflict on TV: A Discourse Analysis of the Gold Medal Mediation Episodes.” China Media Research 9 (4): 5–14.Google Scholar
Dobs, Abby Mueller
2014 “Identities in Conflict: Examining the Co-construction of Impoliteness and Identity in Classroom Interaction.” Journal of Language Aggression and Conflict 2 (1): 36–73. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Donaghue, Helen
2015 The Construction and Negotiation of Identity and Face in Post Observation Feedback. PhD dissertation, Aston University, UK.Google Scholar
2018 “Relational Work and Identity Negotiation in Critical Post Observation Teacher Feedback.” Journal of Pragmatics 1351: 101–116. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Du Bois, John W., Stephan Schuetze-Coburn, Susanna Cumming, and Danae Paolino
1993 “Outline of Discourse Transcription.” In Talking Data: Transcription and Coding in Discourse Research, ed. by Jane A. Edwards, and Martin D. Lampert. 45–89. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Gamson, Joshua
1995 “Must Identity Movements Self-Destruct? A Queer Dilemma.” Social Problems 42 (3): 390–407. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gao, Wenying
2008 “警察调解制度研究 [Study on the Mechanism of Police Mediation].” Journal of Chinese People’s Public Security University 134 (4): 127–134.Google Scholar
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar, Patricia Bou-Franch, and Nuria Lorenzo-Dus
2013 “Identity and Impoliteness: The Expert in the Talent Show Idol.” Journal of Politeness Research 91: 97–121. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar
2018 “Globalization, Transnational Identities, and Conflict Talk: The Superdiversity and Complexity of the Latino Identity.” Journal of Pragmatics 1341: 120–133. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Garcia, Angela Cora
2012 “Advice-giving and Disputant Empowerment in Divorce Mediation Sessions.” Language and Dialogues 2 (3): 398–426. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Habermas, Jürgen
1976 “What Is Universal Pragmatics?” In On the Pragmatics of Communication, ed. by Maeve Cooke, 21–103. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Haugh, Michael
2009 “Face and Interaction.” In Face, Communication and Social Interaction, ed. by Bargiela-Chiappini Francesca, and Michael Haugh, 1–16. London: Equinox.Google Scholar
Heisterkamp, Brian L.
2006 “Conversational Displays of Mediator Neutrality in a Court-based Program.” Journal of Pragmatics 381: 2051–2064. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Jacobs, Scott
2002 “Maintaining Neutrality in Dispute Mediation: Managing Disagreement While Managing Not to Disagree.” Journal of Pragmatics 341: 1403–1426. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Jiang, Ting
2016 “态度系统视阈下仲裁员调解话语的人际意义分析 [On Interpersonal Meanings in Arbitrators’ Mediation Discourse: A Perspective from Attitude System].” Modern Foreign Languages 39 (2): 188–197.Google Scholar
Jin, Ying
2018 “Small Talk in Medical Conversations: Data from China.” Journal of Pragmatics, 1341: 31–44. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ke, Xianbing
2017 “ ‘我(不)想X／Y’ 法庭调解话语策略表达机制研究 [An Empirical Study of Court-related Strategical Mediated Discourse Mechanism: A Case Study of ‘I Don’t Want X/Y’].” Journal of Zhejiang International Studies University 21: 3–11.Google Scholar
Klooster, Susan A. van ’T., Marjolein B. A. van Asselt, and Sjaak P. Koenis
2002 “Beyond the Essential Contestation: Construction and Deconstruction of Regional Identity.” Ethics, Place & Environment 5 (2): 109–121. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Li, Cheng-Tuan, and Yong-Ping Ran
2016 “Self-professional Identity Construction Through Other-identity Deconstruction in Chinese Televised Debating Discourse.” Journal of Pragmatics 941: 47–63. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Li, Cheng-Tuan, Yong-Ping Ran, and Daniel Kádár
2018 “Constructing Self-expert Identity via Other-identity Negation in Chinese Televised Debating Discourse.” Text & Talk 38 (4): 435–455. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Li, Xiangyun, and Chengfang Song
2014 “离婚调解话语中男女权力失衡问题研究 [An Analysis of the Power Imbalance Between Men and Women in Divorce Mediation Discourse].” Journal of Ocean University of China 41:123–128.Google Scholar
Locher, Miriam A.
2011 “Situated Impoliteness: The Interface Between Relational Work and Identity Construction.” In Situated Politeness, ed. by Bethan L. Davies, Michael Haugh, and Andrew John Merrison, 187–208. London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
Locher, Miriam A., Brook Bolander, and Nicole Höhn
2015 “Introducing Relational Work in Facebook and Discussion Boards.” Pragmatics 25 (1): 1–21. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Malinowski, Bronislaw
1923 “The Problem of Meaning in Primitive Languages.” In The Meaning of Meaning, ed. by Charles Kay Ogden, and Ivor Armstrong Richards, 296–336. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Ma, Peipei
2011 “汉语称呼语中“老”字的权势与等同关系探析 [The Power and Solidarity of the Word “Lao” in Chinese Address Terms].” Journal of Hebei North University 27 (2): 42–44.Google Scholar
Marinova, Diana
2007 Neutrality in Mediation Hearing: Managing the Mediation Process without Bias. PhD dissertation, Georgetown University, Washington, D. C.Google Scholar
Morasso, Sara Greco
2011 Argumentation in Dispute Mediation: A Reasonable Way to Handle Conflict. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mullany, Louise
2008 “Impoliteness, Power and Gender Identity in the Professional Workplace.” In Impoliteness in Language, ed. by Derek Bousfield, and Miriam A. Locher, 231–251. The Hague: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Poovey, Mary
1988 “Feminism and Deconstruction.” Feminist Studies 14 (1): 51–65. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ran, Yongping, and Linsen Zhao
2018 “Building Mutual Affection-based Face in Conflict Mediation: A Chinese Relationship Management Model.” Journal of Pragmatics 1291: 185–198. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Richards, Keith
2006 “ ‘Being the Teacher’: Identity and Classroom Conversation.” Applied Linguistics 271: 51–77. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sacks, Harvey
1972 “On the Analyzability of Stories by Children.” In Directions in Sociolinguistics: The Ethnography of Communication, ed. by. John J. Gumperz, and Dell Hymes, 325–345. New York: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Schnurr, Stephanie, and Olga Zayts
2011 “Be(com)ing a Leader: A Case Study of Co-constructing Professional Identities at Work.” In Constructing Identities at Work, ed. by Jo Angouri, and Meredith Marra, 40–60. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Shen, Zhengwei
2015 “民警在治安调解中的效力分析 [Analysis on the Effectiveness of Police in Public Security Mediation].” Journal of Anhui Vocational College of Police Officers 81 (6): 51–54.Google Scholar
Stokoe, Elizabeth, and Rein Sikveland
2016 “Formulating Solutions in Mediation.” Journal of Pragmatics 1051: 101–113. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Tong, Shan
2013 A Conversation-analytic Study of People’ s Mediating Utterances. PhD dissertation, East China Normal University, China.Google Scholar
Tracy, Karen
2002 Everyday Talk: Building and Reflecting Identities. New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
2008 “ ‘Reasonable Hostility’: Situation-appropriate Face-attack.” Journal of Politeness Research 41: 169–191. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
van Dijk, Teun A.
2009 Society and Discourse: How Social Contexts Influence Text and Talk. New York: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Verschueren, Jef
2000 Understanding Pragmatics. Beijing: Foreign Language Teaching and Research Press.Google Scholar
Volpe, Maria R.
2014 “Police and Mediation: Natural, Unimaginable or Both.” In Moving Toward a Just Peace: The Mediation Continuum, ed. by Jan Marie Fritz, 91–105. New York, London: Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wagner, Wolfgang, Peter Holtz, and Yoshihisa Kashima
2009 “Construction and Deconstruction of Essence in Representating Social Groups: Identity Projects, Stereotyping, and Racism.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 39 (3): 363–383. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wall, James, and Michael Blum
1991 “Community Mediation in the People’s Republic of China.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 35 (1): 3–20. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wang, Ting
2014 “完善我国警察调解制度的几点建议 [On Police Mediation in China].” Journal of China Maritime Police Academy 12 (3): 69–75.Google Scholar
Wen, Xu
2018 “言语交际中称谓的认知语用问题 [Cognitive-Pragmatic Aspects of Vocatives in Verbal Communication].” Journal of Zhejiang International Studies University 21: 35–40.Google Scholar
Xu, Youping
2019 “Scolding ‘Brothers’ and Caring ‘Friends’: Discursive Construction of the Identity of China Media Research.” International Journal for the Semiotics of Law 32 (1): 135–153. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Yuan, Zhoumin
2011 An Empirical Study of Medical Consultants’ Pragmatic Identity Construction from the Adaptationist Perspective. PhD dissertation, Nanjing University, China.Google Scholar
Zhao, Lizhi
2017 “中国当代警察身份认同问题探析—体制、文化、社会环境视角 [Identity Struggle of Contemporary Chinese Policemen: from the Perspective of System, Culture and Social Environment].” Journal of Sichuan Police College 29 (2): 7–16.Google Scholar

Full-text

Identity (self-)deconstruction in Chinese police’s civil conflict mediation
Cited by

Cited by 2 other publications

Jiang, Qingsheng
2022. Xinren Chen: Exploring identity work in Chinese communication. Folia Linguistica 56:1 ► pp. 227 ff. Crossref logo
Liu, Hao & Xinren Chen
2021. The identity work of Chinese charities in their online donation-oriented crowdfunding appeals. Discourse, Context & Media 42 ► pp. 100514 ff. Crossref logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 17 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.