Article published In:
PragmaticsVol. 27:1 (2017) ► pp.57–86
Misunderstanding as a resource in interaction
The phenomenon of misunderstanding is a recurrent feature of everyday life – sometimes a source of frustration, sometimes a site of blame. But misunderstandings can also be seen as getting interactants out of (as well as into) trouble. For example, misunderstandings may be produced to deal with disaffiliative implications of ‘not being on the same page,’ and as such they may be deployed as a resource for avoiding trouble. This paper examines misunderstanding as a pragmatic accomplishment, focusing on the uses to which it is put in interactions as a practice for dealing with threats to intersubjectivity: the extent to which persons are aligned in terms of a current referent, activity, assessment, etc. A multimodal discourse analysis of audio and video recordings of naturally-occurring talk inspects moments in which misunderstandings are purported or displayed (rather than overtly invoked) as well as how such misunderstandings are oriented to as simply-repairable references, versus inferential matters more misaligned and potentially fraught. Rather than being a straightforward reflection of an experience of trouble with understanding, misunderstanding may also be collaboratively produced to manage practical challenges to intersubjectivity.
Keywords: Inference, Intersubjectivity, Reference, Misunderstanding, Repair, Discourse analysis
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.
References
Antaki, Charles
2012 “Affiliative and Disaffiliative Candidate Understandings.” Discourse Studies 41: 531–547. 
Bailey, Benjamin
2000 “Communicative Behavior and Conflict between African-American Customers and Korean Immigrant Retailers in Los Angeles.” Discourse & Society 111: 86–108.
Bilmes, Jack
1993 “Ethnomethodology, Culture, and Implicature: Toward an Empirical Pragmatics.” Pragmatics 31: 387–409.
Bocéréan, C., and M. Musiol
Bolden, Galina B., Jenny Mandelbaum, and Sue Wilkinson
2012 “Pursuing a Response by Repairing an Indexical Reference.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 451: 137–155.
Bransford, John D., and Marcia K. Johnson
1972 “Contextual Prerequisites for Understanding: Some Investigations of Comprehension and Recall.” Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 111: 717–726.
Buttny, Richard
2012 Talking Problems: Studies of Discursive Construction. New York: SUNY Press.
Cameron, Deborah
1998 “Is There Any Ketchup, Vera?’: Gender, Power and Pragmatics.” Discourse & Society 91: 437–455.
2001 Working with Spoken Discourse. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Craig, Robert T.
2008 “The Rhetoric of ‘Dialogue’ in Metadiscourse: Possibility-impossibility Arguments and Critical Events.” In Dialogue and Rhetoric, ed. by Edda Weigand, 55–69. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Craig, Robert T., and Karen Tracy
1995 “Grounded Practical Theory: The Case of Intellectual Discussion.” Communication Theory 51: 248–272.
Dingemanse, M., S.G. Roberts, J. Baranova, J. Blythe, P. Drew, S. Floyd, R.S. Gisladottir, K.H. Kendrick, S.C. Levinson, E. Manrique, and G. Rossi
2015 “Universal Principles in the Repair of Communication Problems.” PloS one 101: e0136100.
Drew, Paul
1997 “‘Open’ Class Repair Initiators in Response to Sequential Sources of Troubles in Conversation.” Journal of Pragmatics 281: 69–101.
2012 “What Drives Sequences?” Research on Language & Social Interaction 451: 61–68
Du Bois, John W.
2011 “Co-opting Intersubjectivity: Dialogic Rhetoric of the Self. In The Rhetorical Emergence of Culture, ed. by C. Meyer, and F. Girke, 53–83. Oxford, UK: Berghahn.
Duranti, Alessandro
2008 “Further Reflections on Reading Other Minds.” Anthropological Quarterly 811: 483–494.
Finlay, Linda
2009 “Reflexive Embodied Empathy: A Phenomenology of Participant-researcher Intersubjectivity.” The Humanist Psychologist 331: 271–292.
Ekberg, Stuart
2012 “Addressing a Source of Trouble Outside of the Repair Space.” Journal of Pragmatics 441: 374–386.
Edwards, Derek
2000 “Extreme Case Formulations: Softeners, Investment, and Doing Nonliteral.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 331: 347–373.
Edwards, Derek, and Jonathan Potter
1992 Discursive Psychology. London: Sage.
Eriksson, Mats
2009 “Referring as Interaction: On the Interplay between Linguistic and Bodily Action.” Journal of Pragmatics 411: 240–262.
Fox, Barbara
1999 Directions in Research: Language and the Body. Research on Language and Social Interaction 321: 51–60.
Garfinkel, Harold
1967 Studies in Ethnomethodology. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Gillespie, Alex, and Flora Cornish
2010 “Intersubjectivity: Toward a Dialogical Analysis.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior 401: 19–46.
Goffman, Erving
1978 “Response Cries.” Language 541: 787–815.
Goodwin, Charles
2000 “Action and Embodiment within Situated Human Action.” Journal of Pragmatics 321: 1489–1522.
Goodwin, Marjorie. H.
1983 “Aggravated Correction and Disagreement in Children’s Conversations.” Journal of Pragmatics 71: 657–677.
Haddington, Pentti
2006 “The Organization of Gaze and Assessments as Resources for Stance Taking.” Text & Talk 261: 281–328.
Hall, Barbara
2010 “Interaction is Insufficient: Why we Need Intersubjectivity in Course Room Discourse.” Journal of eLearning and Online Teaching 11: 1–15.
Harwood, Irene N.H., Walter Stone, Walter, and Malcolm Pines
2012 Self Experiences in Group, Revisited: Affective Attachments, Intersubjective Regulations, and Human Understanding. London, UK: Routledge.
Haselow, Alexander
2012 “Subjectivity, Intersubjectivity and the Negotiation of Common Ground in Spoken Discourse: Final Particles in English.” Language & Communication 321: 182–204.
Hayashi, Makoto
2003 “Language and the Body as Resources for Collaborative Action: A Study of Word Searches in Japanese Conversation.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 361: 109–141.
Hayashi, Makoto, Geoffrey Raymond, and Jack Sidnell
2013 “Conversational Repair and Human Understanding: An Introduction.” In Conversational Repair and Human Understanding, ed. by M. Hayashi, G. Raymond, and J. Sidnell, 1–39. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Heath, Christian
2002 “Demonstrative Suffering: The Gestural (Re)embodiment of Symptoms.” Journal of Communication 521: 597–616.
Hepburn, Alexa, Sue Wilkinson, and Rebecca Shaw
2012 “Repairing Self- and Recipient Reference.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 451: 175–190.
Heritage, John
1984 “A Change-of-state Token and Aspects of its Sequential Placement.” In Structures of Social Action, ed. by J.M. Atkinson, and J. Heritage, 299–345. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1984 Garfinkel and Ethnomethodology. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
1987 “Ethnomethodology.” In Social Theory Today, ed. by Anthony Giddens, and Jonathan Turner, 224–272. Cambridge: Polity Press.
2007 “Intersubjectivity and Progressivity in Person (and Place) Reference.” In Person Reference in Interaction: Linguistic, Cultural and Social Perspectives, ed. by N. J. Enfield, and T. Stivers, 255–280. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
2012 “The epistemic Engine: Sequence Organization and Territories of Knowledge.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 451: 30–52.
Hutchby, Ian, and Robin Wooffitt
2008 Conversation Analysis. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Jacquemet, Marco
2005 “Transidiomatic Practices: Language and Power in the Age of Globalization.” Language and Communication 251: 257–277.
Jefferson, Gail
1984 “Transcription Notation.” In Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis, ed. by J.M. Atkinson, and J. Heritage, ix–xi. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Johansson, Eva
2007 “Empathy or Intersubjectivity? Understanding the Origins of Morality in Young Children.” Studies in in Philosophy and Education 271: 33–47.
Johnson-Laird, P.N., and Ruth M.J. Byrne
2002 “Conditionals: A Theory of Meaning, Pragmatics, and Inference.” Psychological Review 109(4) 646-678.
Kärkkäinen, Elise
2007 “Stance Taking in Conversation: From Subjectivity to Intersubjectivity.” Text & Talk 261: 699–731.
Kataoka, K., and Y. Asahi
2015 “Synchronic and Diachronic Variation in the Use of Spatial Frames of Reference: An Analysis of Japanese Route Instruction.” Journal of Sociolinguistics 191: 133–160.
Katriel, Tamar, and Gerry Philipsen
1981 “‘What we Need is Communication’: ‘Communication’ as a Cultural Category in some American Speech.” Communication Monographs 481: 301–317.
Kim, Kyu-Hyun
2001 “Confirming Intersubjectivity through Retroactive Elaboration: Organization of Phrasal Units in Other-initiated Repair Sequences in Korean Conversation.” In Studies in Interactional Sociolinguistics, ed. by M. Selting, and E. Couper-Kuhlen, 345–372. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Koschmann, Timothy
2011 “Guest Editorial: Understanding Understanding in Action.” Journal of Pragmatics 431: 435–437.
Kvale, Steinar
1983 “The Qualitative Research Interview: A Phenomenological and a Hermeneutical Mode of Understanding.” Journal of Phenomenological Psychology 141: 171.
Lerner, Gene H., Galina B. Bolden, Alexa Hepburn, and Jenny Mandelbaum
2012 “Preference Calibration Repairs: Adjusting the Precision of Formulations for the Task at Hand.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 451: 191–212.
Levinson, Stephen
2006 “Cognition at the Heart of Human Interaction.” Discourse Studies 81: 85–93.
Lynch, Michael
2011 “Commentary: On Understanding Understanding.” Journal of Pragmatics 431: 553–555.
Mikesell, Lisa
2014 “Conflicting Demonstrations of Understanding in the Interactions of Individuals with Frontotemporal Dementia: Considering Cognitive Resources and their Implications for Caring and Communication.” In Dialogue and Dementia: Cognitive and Communicative Resources for Engagement, ed. By Robert W. Schrauf, and Nicole Müller, 147–180. Abingdon, UK: Psychology Press.
Mondada, Lorenza
2009 “Emergent Focused Interactions in Public Places: A Systematic Analysis of the Multimodal Achievement of a Common Interactional Space.” Journal of Pragmatics 411: 1977–1997.
2011 “Understanding as an Embodied, Situated and Sequential Achievement in Interaction.” Journal of Pragmatics 431: 542–552.
Mundy, Peter, Connie Kasari, and Marian Sigman
1992 “Nonverbal Communication, Affective Sharing, and Intersubjectivity.” Infant Behavior and Development 151: 377–381.
Muntigl, P. , and K.T. Choi
2010 “Not Remembering as a Practical Epistemic Resource in Couples Therapy.” Discourse Studies 121: 331–356.
Osman, Gihan, and Susan C. Herring
2007 “Interaction, Facilitation, and Deep Learning in Cross-cultural Chat: A Case Study.” The Internet and Higher Education 101: 125–141.
Pomerantz, Anita
1984 “Agreeing and Disagreeing with Assessments: Some Features of Preferred/dispreferred Turn Shapes.” In Structures of Social Action, ed. by J.M. Atkinson, and John Heritage, 57–101. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Robles, Jessida
2011 The Interactive Achievement of Morality in Everyday Talk: A Discourse. Analysis of Moral Practices and Problems in Interpersonal Relationships. Doctoral dissertation, University of Colorado at Boulder.
Robles, Jessica
2012 “Culture in Conversation.” In Inter/cultural Communication: Representation and Construction of Culture in Everyday Interaction, ed. by Anastacia Kurylo, 89–114. Thousand Oak, CA: Sage.
Rochat, Phippe, Cláudia Passos-Ferreira, and Pedro Salem
2009 “Three Levels of Intersubjectivity in Early Development.” In Enacting intersubjectivity: Paving the Way for a Dialogue between Cognitive Science, Social Cognition and Neuroscience, ed. by Antonella Carassa, Francesca Morganti, and Guiseppe Riva, 173–190. Lugano, Switzerland: International Workshop.
Sacks, Harvey
1992 Lectures on Conversation. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Sadler, Misumi
2010 “Subjective and Intersubjective Uses of Japanese Verbs of Cognition in Conversation.” Pragmatics 201: 109–128.
Schegloff, Emanuel A.
1987 “Some Sources of Misunderstanding in Talk-in-Interaction.” Linguistics 251: 201–218.
1992 “Repair after Next Turn: The Last Structurally Provided Defense of Intersubjectivity in Conversation.” American Journal of Sociology 971: 1295–1345.
2007 Sequence Organization in Interaction Volume 1: A Primer in Conversation Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schegloff, Emanuel A., Gail Jefferson, and Harvey Sacks
1977 “The Preference for Self-Correction in the Organization of Repair in Conversation.” Language 531: 361–382.
Scobbie, James M., Sonja Schaeffler, and Ineke Mennen
2011 “Audible Aspects of Speech Preparation.” Proceedings of 17th ICPhS, Hong Kong, 1782–1785.
Senft, Gunter
2016 ““Masawa – bogeokwa si tuta!”: Cultural and Cognitive Implications of the Trobriand Islanders’ Gradual Loss of Their Knowledge of How to Make a Masawa Canoe.” Ethnic and Cultural Dimensions of Knowledge, 229–256. Springer International Publishing.
Sidnell, Jack
2014 “The Architecture of Intersubjectivity Revisited.” In Cambridge Handbook of Linguistic Anthropology, ed. by N.J. Enfield, P. Kockelman, and J. Sidnell, 364–399. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Stivers, Tanya, Lorenza Mondada, and Jakob Steenstig
2011 The Morality of Knowledge in Interaction. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Streeck, Jürgen
1988 “Grammars, Words, and Embodied Meanings: On the Uses and Evolution of so and like.” Journal of Communication 521: 581–596.
Svennevig, Jan
2004 “Other-Repetition as Display of Hearing, Understanding and Emotional Stance.” Discourse Studies 61: 489–516.
2008 “Trying the Easiest Solution First in Other-Initiation of Repair.” Journal of Pragmatics 401: 333–348.
Wilkinson, Ray
1999 “Sequentiality as a Problem and Resource for Intersubjectivity in Aphasic Conversation: Analysis and Implications for Therapy.” Aphasiology 131: 327–343.
Wootton, Anthony J.
1994 “Object Transfer, Intersubjectivity and Third Position Repair: Early Developmental Observations of One Child.” Journal of Child Language 211: 543–564.
Cited by
Cited by 4 other publications
Ablitt, Jonathan
2020. Walking in on people in parks: Demonstrating the orderliness of interactional discomfort in urban territorial negotiations. Emotion, Space and Society 34 ► pp. 100648 ff. 
Elder, Chi-Hé & Michael Haugh
2018. The interactional achievement of speaker meaning: Toward a formal account of conversational inference. Intercultural Pragmatics 15:5 ► pp. 593 ff.
Küttner, Uwe-Alexander & Chase Wesley Raymond
2022. I was gonna say…. In Sprachreflexive Praktiken [LiLi: Studien zu Literaturwissenschaft und Linguistik, 4], ► pp. 51 ff.
Robles, Jessica S. & Theresa Castor
2019. Taking the moral high ground: Practices for being uncompromisingly principled. Journal of Pragmatics 141 ► pp. 116 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 28 may 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.