Differential object marking in P’orhépecha
Split case and fluid case alternations
Alejandra Capistrán Garza | Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana-Iztapalapa
This paper analyzes Differential Object Marking in P’orhépecha, which involves split case and fluid case
alternations. Although this system is sensitive to Animacy and Definiteness, I will show that prominence on these scales does not
account for the distribution of flagging. In fact, in P’orhépecha, the expected prominence effects of these scales are overridden
by certain grammatical properties of the NPs, which explains the obligatory vs. forbidden flagging. The fluid pattern is of
special interest, since even though there is evidence that flagging is used as a device to codify definiteness/specificity, higher
and lower ranked objects on the definiteness scale may be (un)flagged. This peculiar behavior is explained by two facts: (a)
definite/specific descriptions may, and in some instances must, be unflagged when the context of use guarantees the intended
referential interpretation of the NP; and (b) lower ranked objects may be flagged only when their referents exhibit discourse
salience.
Keywords: differential object marking, fluid case marking, split case marking, flagging, animacy, definiteness, specificity
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Differential object marking
- 2.1The definiteness scale
- 3.Methodology
- 4.P’orhépecha and previous proposals about DOM in the language
- 5.Split DOM pattern. Obligatory flagging vs. forbidden flagging
- 5.1Obligatory flagging
- 5.1.1Animacy
- 5.1.2Syntactic definiteness
- 5.1.3Plural NPs with -icha/-echa
- 5.2Forbidden flagging
- 5.3Obligatory vs. forbidden flagging antecedents. The objective case marker in ancient P’orhépecha
- 5.1Obligatory flagging
- 6.Fluid case alternation. DOM and the definiteness dimension
- 6.1Bare indefinite NPs
- 6.2Indefinite inanimate NPs with ma
- 6.3Inanimate definite bare NPs
- 7.Conclusions
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- Abbreviations
- Symbols
-
References
Published online: 12 November 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.16071.cap
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.16071.cap
References
Aissen, Judith
Bickel, Balthasar & Alena Witzlack-Makarevich
Birner, Betty J.
Blansitt, Edward L.
Bohnemeyer, Jürgen
Bossong, Georg
Campbell, Lyle, Terrence Kaufman & Thomas C. Smith-Stark
Capistrán Garza, Alejandra
2002a Variaciones de orden de constituyentes en p’orhépecha. Topicalización y focalización. In Paulette Levy (ed.), Del cora al maya yucateco. Estudios lingüísticos sobre algunas lenguas indígenas mexicanas, 349–402. Mexico: Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Instituto de Investigaciones Filológicas.
Chamoreau, Claudine
Chelliah, Shobhana
Clark, Herbert
Comrie, Bernard
2012 Some argument-structure properties of ‘give’ in the languages of Europe and Northern and Central Asia. In Pirkko Suihkonen, Bernard Comrie & Valery Solovyev (eds.), Argument structure and grammatical relations. A crosslinguistic typology (Studies in Language Companion Series 126). 17–35. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 

Cover, Rebecca & Judith Tonhauser
Czardybon, Adrian
Darlymple, Mary & Irina Nikolaeva
Dayal, Veneeta
de Hoop, Helen & Andrej Malchukov
de Swart, Peter
de Swart, Peter & Helen de Hoop
Dimmendal, Gerrit
Escandell-Vidal, Victoria
Farkas, Donka
Filimonova, Elena
Foster, Mary LeCron
Friedrich, Paul
Gerner, Matthias
Gilberti, Maturino
Givón, Talmy
Gundel, Jeanette, Nancy Hedberg & Ron Zacharski
Haspelmath, Martin
2018 Role-reference associations and the explanation of argument coding splits. Ms., Universität Leipzig, ling.auf.net>lingbuzz/004047
Iemmolo, Giorgo
Johanson, Lars
Kehler, Andrew & Gregory Ward
Kittilä, Seppo & Andrej Malchukov
Kornfilt, Jaklin & Klaus von Heusinger
Lagunas, Juan Baptista de
Levinson, Dmitry
Lucas, Christopher
Malchukov, Andrej
Malchukov, Andrej & Peter de Swart
Matthewson, Lisa
Monzón, Cristina
Morimoto, Yukiko
2002 Prominence mismatches and differential object marking in Bantu. In Miriam Butt & Tracy Holloway King (eds.), Proceedings of the LFG02 Conference, 292–314. Stanford CA: CSLI. http//csli-publications.stanford.edu
Murray, Sarah
Nava, E. Fernando
Næs, Äshild
Prince, Ellen. F.
Schwarz, Florian
Serra, Angel
Seržant, Ilja A. & Alena Witzlack-Makarevich
Silverstein, Michael
Smith-Stark, Thomas C.
Vázquez Rojas, Violeta
Villavicencio, Frida
von Heusinger, Klaus
von Heusinger, Klaus & Jaklin Kornfilt
P’orhépechan texts
Dimas Huacuz, Néstor
Lathrop, Maxwell
Márquez Joaquín, Pedro
Morales Vázquez, Francisco & Néstor Dimas Huacuz
Torres Sánchez, Joel
Santamaría Galván, Ana, Julio Salgado Moya, Juan Cornelio Aparicio & Demetrio Nicolás González
coord. N. d. Uandanskuecha ka arhinskateacha purépecha jimpo. Cuentos y leyendas purépechas Pátzcuaro, Michoacán Centro de Educación Fundamental para América Latina y El Caribe, Jefatura de Zonas de Supervisión de Educación Indígena de Pátzcuaro
juata Juata Akumarhani ka Chupikuarhu anapu. In Santamaría Galván et al., 43–44 (San Jerónimo)
k’uichitiicha Cherasnaspti k’uichitiicha. In Santamaría Galván et al., 831. (Tarerío)
Maria Maria juata. In Santamaría Galván et al., 40–42. (San Jerónimo).
miringua Miringua. In Santamaría Galván et al., 89–95. (San Andrés Tziróndaro)
tata Tata imangi noteru eskampka. In Santamaría Galván et al., 55–56. (Ihuatzio)
tata Pedru Tata Pedru no ambakiti. In Santamaría Galván et al., 25–28. (San Jerónimo)
tembuchati Jimbani tembuchati. In Santamaría Galván et al., 31–32. (San Jerónimo)
tembuna Tembuna ka no ambakiti. In Santamaría Galván et al., 72–77. (Tarerío)
toru Toru miringata jiuatsïo anapu. In Santamaría Galván et al., 60–62. (Ihuatzio)
tumbi Tumbi enga nirajka tembuchani. In Santamaría Galván et al., 103–108. (Ichupio)
tumbi tembuchati Tumbi tembuchati. In Santamaría Galván et al., 78–82. (Tarerío)
tumina Tumina eshenantani. Ms. Recorded in 2012. (Santa Fe de la Laguna)
uajpa Uajpa, Tanti, ka tata k’eri. In Santamaría Galván et al., 371. (San Jerónimo)
uarhuricha Uekanaspti uarhuricha cheranani. In Santamaría Galván et al., 86–88. (San Andrés Tziróndaro)
uekanksï karhani Uekanksï karhani. In Santamaría Galván et al., 84–85. (San Andrés Tziróndaro)