Human impersonal pronouns in West Germanic
A questionnaire-based comparative study of Afrikaans, Dutch and English
Daniël Van Olmen | Lancaster University
Adri Breed | North-West University Potchefstroom
In this article, we examine and compare the main human impersonal pronouns in Afrikaans, Dutch and English. The
second person singular, the third person plural and the ‘man’- and ‘one’-pronouns are studied by means of an acceptability
judgment questionnaire and a completion questionnaire. The combination of the two methods reveals interesting descriptive facts
about the three West Germanic languages. They include, among other things, the ‘man’-prominence of Afrikaans versus the
‘you’-prominence of Dutch and English for expressing the universal meaning ‘anyone’ and the more prominent position of ‘they’ in
Dutch than in the other languages for conveying the existential meaning ‘someone, some people’. Our findings have a number of more
theoretical implications too. The two existing semantic maps for human impersonal pronouns make different distinctions in the
existential domain, based on type/level of (un)knownness on the one hand and number on the other. Our study tests both sets of
distinctions and shows that the two dimensions interact with each other in Afrikaans, Dutch and English. The results thus support
a recent proposal in the literature for a combined semantic map. The data from the completion questionnaire, finally, also
indicates that existential uses prefer alternative forms of impersonalization to human impersonal pronouns in all three
languages.
Keywords: acceptability, Afrikaans, completion, Dutch, English, impersonal pronoun, questionnaire, semantic map
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Methodology
- 2.1Acceptability judgment questionnaire
- 2.2Completion questionnaire
- 2.3Earlier questionnaires
- 2.4Delivery and participants
- 2.5Statistics
- 3.Universal-internal uses
- 3.1Acceptability judgment task
- 3.2Completion task
- 3.3Interim conclusion
- 4.Non-universal-internal uses
- 4.1Acceptability judgment task
- 4.2Completion task
- 4.3Interim conclusion
- 5.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
Published online: 04 February 2019
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.18036.van
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.18036.van
References
Baayen, R. Harald
Bard, Ellen G., Dan Robertson & Antonella Sorace
Cabredo Hofherr, Patricia
2010 Binding properties of impersonal human pronouns in generic and episodic contexts. http://archive.sfl.cnrs.fr/sites/sfl/IMG/pdf/impersMay2010CabredoHofherrManOnLa.pdf (6 April 2017.)
Cheshire, Jenny
Coussé, Evie & Johan van der Auwera
De Hoop, Helen & Sammie Tarenskeen
Deringer, Lisa, Volker Gast, Florian Haas & Olga Rudolf
Duinhoven, A. M.
Fonesca-Greber, Bonnie & Linda R. Waugh
Gast, Volker
2017 Online database for a typology of human impersonal pronouns. http://www.personal.uni-jena.de/~mu65qev/improtype (4 July 2017.)
Gast, Volker, Lisa Deringer, Florian Haas & Olga Rudolf
Gast, Volker & Johan van der Auwera
Giacalone Ramat, Anna & Andrea Sansò
Greenbaum, Sidney & Randolph Quirk
Hoekstra, Jarich
Hofmeister, Philip, T. Florian Jaeger, Ivan Sag, Inbal Arnon & Neal Snider
Kirsten, Johanita
Posio, Pekka & Maria Vilkuna
Rasinger, Sebastian M.
Siewierska, Anna & Maria Papastathi
Sprouse, Jon & Diogo Almeida
van der Auwera, Johan
van der Auwera, Johan, Volker Gast & Jeroen Vanderbiesen
van der Auwera, Johan & Vladimir A. Plungian
Van Olmen, Daniël & Adri Breed
Van Olmen, Daniël, Adri Breed & Ben Verhoeven
2019 A corpus-based study of the human impersonal pronoun (’n) mens in Afrikaans: Compared to men and een mens in Dutch. Languages in Contrast 19(1). 79–105.
Weerman, Fred
2006 It’s the economy, stupid: Een vergelijkende blik op men en man
[It’s the economy, stupid: A comparative look at men en man
]. In Matthias Hüning, Ulrike Vogl, Ton van der Wouden & Arie Verhagen (eds.), Nederlands tussen Duits en Engels [Dutch between German and English], 19–47. Leiden: Stichting Neerlandistiek Leiden.
Zifonun, Gisela
Cited by
Cited by 3 other publications
Breed, Adri, Jo-Ann Chan & Daniël van Olmen
Breed, Adri & Daniël Van Olmen
Rădulescu, Valentin & Daniël Van Olmen
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 18 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.