Article published in:
Studies in Language
Vol. 46:1 (2022) ► pp. 76–132

Non-culmination in two Bantu languages

| University of Hamburg | Rhodes University
This paper describes an exploratory approach to two related aspectual phenomena, non-culminating accomplishments and non-culminating construals of implied-result verbs, in the Bantu languages Xhosa and Nyakyusa. While documented for a diverse array of languages, leading to the identification of some cross-linguistic commonalities and axes of variation, these phenomena have so far not been studied for any continental African language. Both Xhosa and Nyakyusa license non-culminating accomplishments but differ regarding the felicity of such construals with different sub-types of accomplishments in relation to event progress, a decisive factor being that Nyakyusa possesses verbal partitive morphology. Concerning the non-culmination of implied-result verbs, both languages show such readings and support prior cross-linguistic findings that zero change readings are more readily available with agentive subjects. The data further point to the potential role of causative morphology as a parameter of variation to be considered in further comparative research on these verbs.
Keywords: aspect, actionality, aktionsart, non-culminating accomplishments, Bantu languages
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
    • 1.1Non-culmination
    • 1.2Non-culmination cross-linguistically, and in the African context
    • 1.3Goal and scope of the present study
    • 1.4Definitions
  • 2.The languages under study
    • 2.1Geographic, demographic and genetic background
    • 2.2Morphosyntactic profile and the structure of the verb
    • 2.3Outline of tense-aspect systems
    • 2.4The Nyakyusa partitive
  • 3.Data collection
  • 4.Non-culminating accomplishments
    • 4.1Delimiting NCAs
    • 4.2NCAs in Xhosa and Nyakyusa: A first look
    • 4.3Cross-linguistic axes of variation
    • 4.4Predicates examined
    • 4.5Culmination vs. termination
    • 4.6Felicity depending on event progress and predicate class
      • 4.6.1Non-motion verbs
      • 4.6.2Motion verbs
    • 4.7Numerical plural objects
    • 4.8NCAs and the Xhosa conjoint-disjoint alternation
    • 4.9Intermediate summary
  • 5.Non-culminating readings of implied-result verbs
    • 5.1Defining implied-result verbs
    • 5.2Implied-result verbs in Xhosa and Nyakyusa: A first look
    • 5.3Cross-linguistic observations on implied-result verbs
    • 5.4Predicates examined
    • 5.5Morphological causatives and non-culminating readings
    • 5.6The role of subject agency
    • 5.7Implied-result verbs and the Xhosa conjoint/disjoint alternation
    • 5.8Intermediate summary
  • 6.Conclusion and outlook
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • Abbreviations
  • References
Published online: 25 March 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.20051.per
References
Alexiadou, Artemis, Fabienne Martin & Florian Schäfer
2017 Optionally causative manner verbs: When implied results get entailed. Available at: https://​amor​.cms​.hu​-berlin​.de​/~schaeffl​/papers​/roots​-final​.pdf (last access 16 February 2021).
Arche, María J.
2017 Perfective but incomplete accomplishments. Available at https://​gala​.gre​.ac​.uk​/id​/eprint​/16482​/1​/16482%20ARCHE​_Perfective​_But​_Incomplete​_Accomplishments​_2017​.pdf (last access 16 February 2021).
Asiimwe, Allen
2014 Definiteness and specificity in Runyankore-Rukiga. Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University PhD dissertation.Google Scholar
Bar-el, Leora
2015 Documenting and identifying aspectual classes across languages. In M. Ryan Bochnak & Lisa Matthewson (eds.), Methodologies in semantic fieldwork, 75–109. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bar-el, Leora, Henry Davis & Lisa Matthewson
2005 On non-culminating accomplishments. In Leah Bateman & Cherlon Ussery (eds.), Proceedings of the 35th annual meeting of the North East Linguistics Society, 87–102. Amherst: GSLA Publications.Google Scholar
Bastin, Yvonne
1983 La finale verbale -ide et l’imbrication en bantou. Tervuren: Musee Royale de l’Afrique Centrale.Google Scholar
Boyd, Jeremy K. & Adele E. Goldberg
2011 Learning what NOT to say: the role of statistical preemption and categorization in a-adjective production. Language 87(1). 55–83. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Budd, Peter
2014 Partitives in Oceanic languages. In Silvia Luraghi & Thomas Huumo (eds.), Partitive cases and related categories, 523–561. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Carstens, Vicki & Loyiso Mlethse
2019 (In-)definiteness without articles in two Bantu languages. Available at http://​www​.lagb​.org​.uk​/resources​/Documents​/Carstens​_Mletshe​.pdf (last access 16 February 2021).
Chen, Sihwei
2017 Initial stages of events: the Atayal unmarked predicates. In Aaron Kaplan, Abby Kaplan, Miranda K. McCarvel & Edward J. Rubin (eds.), Proceedings of the 34th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 107–114. Somerville: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.Google Scholar
Civardi, Eugenio & Pier Marco Bertinetto
2015 The semantics of degree verbs and the telicity issue. Borealis – An International Journal of Hispanic Linguistics 40(1). 57–77. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Crane, Thera & Bastian Persohn
2019a What’s in a Bantu verb? Actionality in Bantu languages. Linguistic Typology 23(2). 303–345. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2019b A model-theoretic discussion of Bantu actionality. Africana Linguistica 251. 27–63.Google Scholar
Creissels, Denis, Gerrit J. Dimmendaal, Zygmunt Frajzingier & Christa König
2008 Africa as a morphosyntactic area. In Bernd Heine & Derek Nurse (eds.), A linguistic geography of Africa, 105–150. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Demirdache, Hamida & Fabienne Martin
2015 Agent control over non-culminating events. In Elisa Barrajón López, José Luis Cifuentes Honrubia & Susana Rodríguez Rosique (eds.), Verb classes and aspect, 185–217. Amsterdam: Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Dixon, Robert M. W.
1982 Where have all the adjectives gone? Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Doke, Clemens Martyn
1954 The Southern Bantu languages. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Filip, Hana
1999 Aspect, eventuality types, and nominal reference. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Goddard, Cliff
2001 Lexico-semantic universals: a critical overview. Linguistic Typology 51. 1–65. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gowlett, Derek
2003 Zone S. In Derek Nurse & Gérard Philippson (eds.), The Bantu languages, 609–638. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Grégoire, Claire
1975 Les locatifs en bantou. Tervuren: Musée royal de l’Afrique centrale.Google Scholar
Guéron, Jacqueline & Svetlana Vogeleer
2019 Non-culminating accomplishments: subject, speaker and syntactic structure. Unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
Guthrie, Malcolm
1971 Comparative Bantu: An introduction to the comparative linguistics and prehistory of the Bantu languages. Vol. 2: Bantu prehistory, inventory and indexes. London: Gregg International.Google Scholar
Güldemann, Tom
1999 The genesis of verbal negation in Bantu and its dependency on functional features of clause types. In Jean-Marie Hombert & Larry M. Hyman (eds.), Bantu historical linguistics, 545–587. Stanford: Centre for the Study of Language and Information.Google Scholar
Gyamarthy, Zsófia & Daniel Gordonn Altshuler
2020 (Non)culmination by abduction. Linguistics 58(5). 1373–1411. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Haspelmath, Martin
2010 Comparative concepts and descriptive categories in crosslinguistic studies. Language 86(3). 663–687. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hay, Jennifer, Christopher Kennedy & Beth Levin
1999 Scalar structure underlies telicity in “degree achievements”. Semantics and Linguistic Theory 91.127–144. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Koenig, Jean-Pierre & Lian-Cheng Chief
2008 Scalarity and state-changes in Mandarin (and other languages). Empirical Issues in Syntax and Semantics 71. 241–262.Google Scholar
Koenig, Jean-Pierre & Nuttantart Muansuwan
2000 How to end without ever finishing: Thai semi-perfectivity. Journal of Semantics 171. 147–184. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Koptjevskaja-Tamm, Maria, Martine Vanhove & Peter Koch
2007 Typological appraoches to lexical semantics. Linguistic Typology 11(1). 159–185. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Levin, Beth & Malka Rappaport Hovav
2005 Argument realization. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lin, Jimmy
2004 Event structure and the encoding of arguments: The syntax of the Mandarin and English verb phrase. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology doctoral dissertation.Google Scholar
Maho, Jouni Filip
2009 NUGL Online: The online version of the new updated Guthrie list, a referential classification of the Bantu languages. Available at https://​brill​.com​/fileasset​/downloads​_products​/35125​_Bantu​-New​-updated​-Guthrie​-List​.pdf (last access 16 February 2021).
Martin, Fabienne
2019 Non-culminating accomplishments. Language and Linguistics Compass 13(8). e12346. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Martin, Fabienne & Florian Schäfer
2012 The modality of ‘offer’ and other defeasible causatives. In Nathan Arnett & Ryan Bennett (eds.), Proceedings of the 30th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 248–258. Somerville: Cascadilla Procedings Project.Google Scholar
2013 On the argument structure of of verbs with bi- and mono-eventive uses. In Stefan Keine & Shayne Slogget (eds.), Proceedings of the 42nd Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society, 297–308. Amherst: GLSA.Google Scholar
2017 Sublexical modality in defeasible causative verbs. In Ana Arregui, María Luisa Rivero & Andrés Salanova (eds.), Modality across syntactic categories, 97–108. Oxford: Oxford University press.Google Scholar
Martin, Fabienne & Hamida Demirdache
2020 Partitive accomplishments across languages. Linguistics 58(5). 1192–1232. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Martin, Fabienne, Margaret Grant, Florian Schäfer & Christopher Piñón
2019 Non-culminating telic path descriptions. Paper presented at the Workshop on Event Semantics, Humboldt University of Berlin, November 1, 2019.
Martin, Fabienne, Zsófia Gyamarthy & Károly Varasdi
2016 On non-culminating interpretations of telic predicates. Fall School on Tense, Mood, and Aspect. Paris 5 & 7 November 2016.Google Scholar
Matthewson, Lisa
2004 On the methodology of semantic fieldwork. International Journal of American Linguists 70(4). 369–415. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McLaren, James
1936 A Xhosa grammar. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
Meeussen, A. E.
1967 Bantu lexical reconstructions. Africana Linguistica 31. 80–122. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mous, Maarten
2007 Language documentation as a challenge to description. Available at http://​home​.planet​.nl​/~gongg010​/veldwerk​/Language%20documentation%20as%20a%20challenge​_article​.pdf (last access 17 February 2021).
Muzale, Henry R. T. & Josephat M. Rugemalira
2008 Researching and documenting the languages of Tanzania. Language Documentation & Conservation 2(1). 68–108.Google Scholar
Nakazawa, Tsuneko
2006 Motion event and decitic motion verbs as path-conflating verbs. In Stefan Müller (ed.), Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Head Driven Phrase Structure Grammar, 284–304. Stanford: Centre for the Study of Language and Information.Google Scholar
Nurse, Derek
2008 Tense and aspect in Bantu. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Oehrle, Richard Thomas
1976 The grammatical status of the English dative alternation. Cambridge: Massachussetes Institute of Technology doctoral dissertation.Google Scholar
Ogiela, Diane, Cristina Schmitt & Michael Casby
2014 Interpretation of verb phrase telicity: Sensitivity to verb type and determiner type. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 3(57). 865–875. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Oosthuysen, Jacobus Christian
2016 The grammar of isiXhosa. Stellenbosch: African Sun Media. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pan South African Language Board
2008 Spelling and orthography rules for isiXhosa.Google Scholar
Paul, Ileana, Baholisa Simone Ralalaoherivony & Henriette de Swart
2015 Aspect and modality in Malagasy maha. In Santa Vinerte (ed.), Proceedings of the 2015 Annual Conference of the Canadian Linguistic Association. Ottawa: Canadian Linguistics Society.Google Scholar
2016 Malagasy maha at the crossroads of voice, causation and modality. In Emily Clem, Virginia Dawson, Alice Shen, Amalia Skilton, Geoff Bacon, Andrew Cheng & Erik Maier (eds.), Proceedings of the 42nd meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, 353–368. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistics Society, University of California.Google Scholar
2020 Culminating and non-culminating accomplishments in Malagasy. Linguistics 58(5). 1285–1322. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pederson, Eric
2008 Event realization in Tamil. In Melissa Bowerman & Penelope Brown (eds.), Crosslinguistic perspectives on argument structure: implications for learnability, 331–355. Mahwah: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Persohn, Bastian
2017a The verb in Nyakyusa: A focus on tense, aspect, and modality. Berlin: Language Science Press.Google Scholar
2017b Locative and extra-locative clitics in Nyakyusa. Africana Linguistica 231. 151–165.Google Scholar
Persohn, Bastian & Maud Devos
2017 Post-final locatives in Bantu: Axes of variation and non-locative functions. Africana Linguistica 231. 3–46.Google Scholar
Piñón, Christopher
2008 Verbs of creation. In Johannes Dölling, Tatjana Heyde-Zybatow, and Martin Schäfer (eds.), Event structures in linguistic form and interpretation, 493–521. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Plessis, Jacobus A. du & Marianna Visser
1992 Xhosa syntax. Pretoria: Via Afrika.Google Scholar
Rappaport Hovav, Malka & Beth Levin
1998 Building verb meanings. In Miriam Butt & Wilhelm Geuder (eds.), The projection of arguments: lexical and compositional factors, 97–134. Stanford: Centre for the Study of Language and Information.Google Scholar
Ryle, Gilbert
1949 The concept of mind. New York: Barnes & Nobles.Google Scholar
Samarin, William J.
1971 Survey of Bantu ideophones. African Language Studies 121. 130–168.Google Scholar
Sasse, Hans-Jürgen
2002 Recent activity in the theory of aspect: Accomplishments, achievements, or just non-progressive state? Linguistic Typology 6(2). 199–271. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Savić, Stefan
2020 Tense and aspect in Xhosa. Makhanda: Rhodes University PhD dissertation.Google Scholar
2017 The perfective and imperfective aspects in Xhosa. Stellenbosch Papers in Linguistics Plus 521. 45–72. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Simons, Gary F. & Charles D. Fenning
(eds.) 2017 Ethnologue: Languages of the world. 22nd edn. Dallas: SIL International.Google Scholar
Singh, Mona
1994 Perfectivity, definiteness and specificity: A classification of verbal predicates in Hindi. Austin: University of Texas PhD dissertation.Google Scholar
1998 On the semantics of the perfective aspect. Natural Language Semantics 61. 171–199. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Carlota S.
1997 The parameter of aspect. 2nd edn. Dordrecht: Kluwer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Soh, Hooi Ling & Jenny Yi-Chun Kuo
2005 Perfective aspect and accomplishment situations in Mandarin Chinese. In Henk Verkuyl, Henriette de Swart & Angeliek van Hout (eds.), Perspectives on aspect, 199–216. Berlin: Springer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Talmy, Leonard
1991 Path to realization: a typology of event conflation. In Laurel A. Sutton, Christopher Johnson & Ruth Shields (eds.), Proceedings of the 17th annual meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, 480–519. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistics Society, University of California. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2000 Towards a cognitive semantics. Vol. 2: Typology and process in concept structuring. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Tatevosov, Sergei
2020 On the temporal structure of non-culminating accomplishments. Linguistics 58(5). 1323–1371. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Tatevosov, Sergei & Mikhail Ivanov
2009 Event structure of non-culminating accomplishments. In Lotte Helweg, Helen de Hoop & Andrej L. Malchukov (eds.), Cross-linguistic semantics of tense, aspect, and modality, 83–130. Amsterdam: Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Thepkanjana, Kingkarn & Satoshi Uehara
2009 Resultative constructions with “implied-result” and “entailed-result” verbs in Thai and English: a contrastive study. Linguistics 47(3). 590–618. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Trąba, Kamil
2019 The notion of completion in Modern Greek: An analysis of aspectively adversative sentences. Poznań: Adam Mickiewicz University PhD dissertation.Google Scholar
Travis, Lisa
2010 Inner aspect. The articulation of VP. Amsterdam: Springer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2015 Agents and causes in Malagasy and Tagalog. In Nomi Erteschik-Schir & Tova Rapoport (eds.), The syntax of aspect: Deriving thematic and aspectual interpretation, 174–189. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Van de Velde, Mark, Koen Bostoen, Derek Nurse & Gérard Phillippson
(eds) 2019 The Bantu languages. 2nd edn. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Van der Wal, Jenneke
2017 What is the conjoint/disjoint alternation? Parameters of crosslinguistic variation. In Van der Wal, Jenneke & Larry M. Hyman (eds.), The conjoint/disjoint alternation in Bantu, 14–60. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Vendler, Zeno
1957 Verbs and times. The Philosophical Review 661. 143–160.Google Scholar