Many schools of modern linguistics generally adopt a rigid approach to categorisation by not allowing degrees of form class membership, degrees of resemblance to a prototype or overlaps between categories. This all-or-none conception of categorisation (Bolinger 1961) goes back to Aristotle, and has been pervasive and influential, especially in formal linguistics. The alternative view, prevalent amongst descriptive and cognitive linguists, is to posit grammars which pervasively display categorial vagueness, more usually called gradience. In this article I will begin by briefly tracing some of the ideas on gradience in linguistics and philosophy. I will then argue, firstly, that gradience should have a role to play in language studies (both descriptive and theoretical). Secondly, I will show that two types of category fluidity should be distinguished. One type I will call Subsective Gradience (SG). It is intra-categorial in nature, and allows for members of a class to display the properties of that class to varying degrees. The other type is called Intersective Gradience (IG). This is an inter-categorial phenomenon which is characterised by two form classes ‘converging’ on each other. Thirdly, I will argue that while the two types of gradience are grammatically real, IG is not as widespread as is often claimed. Finally, in this article I will attempt to be more precise about the vague phenomenon of gradience. To this end I will devise a formalisation of SG and IG, using a number of case studies mainly from English. The formalism makes use of morphosyntactic tests to establish whether an item belongs to a particular class or to a ‘bordering’ one by weighing up the form class features that apply to the item in question. This article can be seen to argue for a midway position between the Aristotelian and the cognitivist conceptions of categorisation in that I will defend a position that allows for gradience, but nevertheless maintains sharp boundaries between categories. The ideas put forward in this article have wider implications for the study of language, in that they address the problem posed by the existence of a tension between generally rigidly conceived linguistic concepts and the continuous phenomena they describe.
2005. Gradience, Constructions and Constraint Systems. In Constraint Solving and Language Processing [Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 3438], ► pp. 74 ff.
Brinton, Laurel J. & Elizabeth Closs Traugott
2005. Lexicalization and Language Change,
Cominetti, Federica & Raffaele Simone
2017. Encoding dot-like events in Modern Standard Chinese. Language Sciences 62 ► pp. 1 ff.
Deulofeu, José & André Valli
2020. Lexique et classement en parties du discours dans ORFÉO. Langages N° 219:3 ► pp. 53 ff.
Duchier, Denys, Jean-Philippe Prost & Thi-Bich-Hanh Dao
2011. A Model-Theoretic Framework for Grammaticality Judgements. In Formal Grammar [Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 5591], ► pp. 17 ff.
Duffield, Nigel G. & Ayumi Matsuo
2009. NATIVE SPEAKERS’ VERSUS L2 LEARNERS’ SENSITIVITY TO PARALLELISM IN VP-ELLIPSIS. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 31:1 ► pp. 93 ff.
Enger, Hans-Olav
2013. Morphological theory and grammaticalisation: the role of meaning and local generalisations. Language Sciences 36 ► pp. 18 ff.
Giannaris, Thanasis
2023. The Development of the Copular Participial Periphrases in Ancient Greek: Evidence for Syntactic Change and Reconstruction. In Internal and External Causes of Language Change, ► pp. 119 ff.
González‐Díaz, Victorina
2009. Little old problems: adjectives and subjectivity in the English NP. Transactions of the Philological Society 107:3 ► pp. 376 ff.
He, Qingshun
2020. A Corpus-based Study of Transfers in English Nominal Groups. Glottotheory 10:1-2 ► pp. 57 ff.
Heyvaert, Liesbet, Stefan Hartmann & Hubert Cuyckens
2019. Categorial shift: from description to theory and back again. Language Sciences 73 ► pp. 1 ff.
Heyvaert, Liesbet, Charlotte Maekelberghe & Anouk Buyle
2019. Nominal and verbal gerunds in present-day English: aspectual features and nominal status. Language Sciences 73 ► pp. 32 ff.
Jäger, Gerhard & Anette Rosenbach
2008. Priming as a testing ground for historical linguists? – A reply to Chang, Eckardt and Traugott. Theoretical Linguistics 34:2
Kemmerer, David
2014. Word classes in the brain: Implications of linguistic typology for cognitive neuroscience. Cortex 58 ► pp. 27 ff.
Kuteva, Tania, Bas Aarts, Gergana Popova & Anvita Abbi
2011. Wohlgeformtheit als empirisches Konzept. Zeitschrift für angewandte Linguistik 2011:55
Mitkovska, Liljana, Eleni Bužarovska & Elena Ju. Ivanova
2017. Apprehensive-epistemic Da-Constructions in Balkan Slavic. Slovene 6:2 ► pp. 57 ff.
Paoli, Sandra
2024. Gradualness of Grammaticalization and Abrupt Change Reconciled: Evidence from Microvariation in Romance. Languages 9:4 ► pp. 138 ff.
Pendar, Nick
2008. Linguistic Constraint Systems as General Soft Constraint Satisfaction. Research on Language and Computation 6:2 ► pp. 163 ff.
Peng, Rui
2016. The integration of exemplars and prior knowledge in the extension of schematic constructions: evidence from Chinese emerge-hide construction. Language Sciences 56 ► pp. 1 ff.
Pil-Hwan Lee
2008. On the Notion of Complement: To Advocate Fuzzy Grammar. English Language and Linguistics null:25 ► pp. 171 ff.
Rodríguez-Puente, Paula
2019. The English Phrasal Verb, 1650–Present,
Rohrmeier, Martin, Willem Zuidema, Geraint A. Wiggins & Constance Scharff
2015. Principles of structure building in music, language and animal song. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 370:1664 ► pp. 20140097 ff.
Urrutia, Adria Torrens, Maria Dolores Jimenez Lopez & Philippe Blache
2017. 2017 IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems (FUZZ-IEEE), ► pp. 1 ff.
Van de Velde, Freek
2009. Do we need the category of postdeterminer in the NP?1. Transactions of the Philological Society 107:3 ► pp. 293 ff.
Van de Velde, Freek
2019. Wayward categorial shift: so odd an article. Language Sciences 73 ► pp. 146 ff.
Van Goethem, Kristel & Nikos Koutsoukos
2018. “Morphological transposition” as the onset of recategorization: The case of luxe in Dutch. Linguistics 56:6 ► pp. 1369 ff.
Vartiainen, Turo
2021. Trends and Recent Change in the Syntactic Distribution of Degree Modifiers: Implications for a Usage-based Theory of Word Classes. Journal of English Linguistics 49:2 ► pp. 228 ff.
Wagner, Thomas
2023. Irregular Verb Morphology: Theoretical Accounts. In English Interlanguage Morphology, ► pp. 15 ff.
Wagner, Thomas
2023. Irregular Verb Morphology: L1 and L2 Cognitive Accounts. In English Interlanguage Morphology, ► pp. 31 ff.
Weinert, Regina
2013. Presentational/Existential Structures in Spoken versus Written German: Es Gibt and SEIN. Journal of Germanic Linguistics 25:1 ► pp. 37 ff.
YONEKURA, YOKO
2012. <i>Gradience, Gradualness and Grammaticalization</i>. ENGLISH LINGUISTICS 29:2 ► pp. 516 ff.
Zehentner, Eva
2022. Revisiting Gradience in Diachronic Construction Grammar: PPs and the Complement-Adjunct Distinction in the History of English. Zeitschrift für Anglistik und Amerikanistik 70:3 ► pp. 301 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 16 june 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.