Part of
The Evidential Basis of Linguistic ArgumentationEdited by András Kertész and Csilla Rákosi
[Studies in Language Companion Series 153] 2014
► pp. 199–218
Edited by András Kertész and Csilla Rákosi
[Studies in Language Companion Series 153] 2014
► pp. 199–218
Chapter 8. A plausibility-based model of shifted indexicals
In his groundbreaking formal work on context-dependent expressions, Kaplan (1989a) argued that the conventional meaning of natural language indexicals cannot be modified by sentential operators. Kaplan’s original theory, however, has been recently challenged by empirical studies. It turned out that in certain languages, for example in Amharic and Zazaki, attitude operators are able to modify the meaning of indexicals. Some of these empirical findings appear to be clearly inconsistent with the Kaplanian account. From a metatheoretical point of view, the current debate about the operator-sensitivity of indexicals can also be interpreted as a debate about the role of linguistic data. In following the p-model and considering linguistic data as statements with plausibility values, one can make some progress in this field of research.
References
Anand, Pranav
2006 De de se. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
Anand, Pranav & Nevins, Andrew
2004 Shifty operators in changing contexts. In
Proceedings of the 14th Conference on Semantics and Linguistic Theory
, Kazuha Watanabe & Robert B. Young (eds), 20–37. Ithaca NY: CLC Publications.
Ball, Derek
2006 Bound variables and monstrous semantics. Paper presented at
The 34th Annual Meeting of the Society for Exact Philosophy
.
Büring, Daniel
2005 Binding Theory. Cambridge: CUP. 
Cable, Seth
2005 Binding local person pronouns without semantically empty features. Unpublished manuscript, MIT, [URL].
Heim, Irene
2004
Puzzling reflexive pronouns in de se reports
. Unpublished handout (presented at Bielefeld) 22 December 2004, [URL]
Kaplan, David
1989a Demonstratives. In
Themes from Kaplan
, Joseph Almog, John Perry & Howard Wettstein (eds), 481–563. Oxford: OUP.
1989b Afterthoughts. In
Themes from Kaplan
, Joseph Almog, John Perry & Howard Wettstein (eds), 565–614. Oxford: OUP.
Kertész, András & Rákosi, Csilla
2006 Inconsistency and plausible reasoning in an analysis of German affricates. A case study in the philosophy of linguistics.
Language Sciences
28: 386–423.
2012
Data and Evidence in Linguistics. A Plausible Argumentation Model
. Cambridge: CUP.
this volume. The p-model of data and evidence in linguistics.
Kratzer, Angelika
1998
More structural analogies between pronouns and tenses
. In SALT VIII, Devon Strolovitch & Anna Lawson (eds), 92–110. Amherst MA: GLSA.
Magnani, Lorenzo
2009
Abductive Cognition
. Berlin: Springer.
Rescher, Nicholas
1976
Plausible Reasoning
. Assen: Van Gorcum.
2003
Epistemology: An Introduction to the Theory of Knowledge
. Albany NY: State University of New York Press.
Schlenker, Philippe
2003a Indexicality, logophoricity, and plural pronouns. In
Research in Afroasiatic Grammar
II.
Selected Papers from the Fifth Conferenceon Afroasiatic Languages, Paris
2000 [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory 241], Jacqueline Lecarme (ed.), 409–428. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
2003b A plea for monsters.
Linguistics and Philosophy
26: 29–120.
Sharvit, Yael
2004 Free indirect discourse and de re pronouns. In
Proceedings of Semantics and Linguistic Theory (SALT)
14, Robert B. Young (ed.), 305–322. Ithaca NY: CLC Publications.
Sidelle, Alan
1991 The answering machine paradox.
Canadian Journal of Philosophy
81: 525–539.
Speas, Margaret
2000 Person and point of view in Navajo. In
WCCFL Papers in Honor of Ken Hale
, Eloise Jelinek (ed.), 19–38. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
von Stechow, Arnim
2003 Feature deletion under semantic binding: Tense, person, and mood under verbal quantifiers. In NELS 33.
Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society
, Makoto Kadowaki & Shigeto Kawahara (eds), 379–404. Amherst MA: GLSA.