Polycategoriality and hybridity across Mayan languages
Action nouns and ergative splits
This article presents a comparative study of Mayan languages belonging to three different branches (Cholan, Tseltalan and Yucatecan), with respect to polycategoriality. Mayan languages appear to be particularly interesting for exploring polycategoriality for several structural reasons, as well as for the way relevant properties vary across the Mayan family. We analyze levels and processes of categorial determination and their relationship with other facts, in particular the ergative splits (aspectual and agentive). We study morphophonological, morphosyntactic and semantic properties for evaluating polycategoriality at the root or stem level. At the structure level, we put forth the hypothesis of a hybrid nature based on simultaneous nominal and verbal properties. For some cases, a reanalysis from nominal to verbal stems is proposed.
Article outline
- Introduction
- 1.Three contrasting Mayan branches: Yucatecan, Cholan, Tseltalan
- 2.Main word-formation patterns for V/N changes and polycategoriality
- 2.1The semantics of nouns in possible polycategorial pairs
- 2.2Implications for roots and lexical categories
- 3.Polycategoriality and the aspectual split
- 3.1
Action nouns and the imperfective: Main constructions
- 3.2The role of Aspect in imperfective constructions
- 3.2.1Aspect as main predicate
- 3.2.2The prepositional construction (PC)
- 3.2.3Direct combination with Aspect (DCA)
- 3.2.3.1Contrasting properties of Aspect markers
- 3.2.3.2DCA in Yucatecan languages
- 3.2.3.3DCA in Cholan languages and Tseltal
- 3.2.4Adverbial distribution in PC and DCA
- 3.2.5The –Vl suffix
- 3.3Conclusive remarks on imperfective forms, hybridity and polycategoriality
- 4.Agentives and the agentive split
- 4.1Agentives in Yucatecan languages
- 4.2Agentives in Cholan languages
- 4.3An agentive/non-agentive distinction in Tseltal?
- 5.Conclusion
-
Notes
-
References
References (61)
Arad, M
2005 Roots and Patterns. Hebrew Morpho-syntax. Dordrecht: Springer.
Armstrong, G
2009 On copular sentences in Yucatec Maya.
Proceedings of the Conference on Indigenous Languages of Latin America-IV
.
[URL] (8 November 2015).
Baker, M.C
2003 Lexical Categories: Verbs, Nouns, and Adjectives. Cambridge: CUP.
Becquey, C
2014 Diasystème, diachronie: Etudes comparées dans les langues cholanes. Utrecht: LOT (Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics).
[URL].
Berlin, B
1968 Tzeltal Numeral Classifiers. A Study in Ethnographic Semantics. The Hague: Mouton.
Berlin, B. & Kaufman, T
1977 Diccionario tzeltal de Tenejapa, Chiapas [
Microfilm Collection of Manuscripts on Cultural Anthropology, Series LIII, 281]. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Library.
Bohnemeyer, J
1998 Time Relations in Discourse. Evidence from a Comparative Approach to Yukatek Maya. PhD dissertation, Katholieke Universiteit Brabant.
Briceño Chel, F
1997 De gramaticalización y degramaticalización: Dos procesos en el maya yucateco actual. MA dissertation, Escuela Nacional de Antropología e Historia, México.
Bricker, V
1978 Antipassive constructions in Yucatec Maya. In
Papers in Mayan Linguistics,
N. England (ed.), 3–24. Columbia MO: University of Missouri.
Bricker, V
1981 The source of the ergative split in Yukatek Maya.
Journal of Mayan Linguistics 2(2): 83–127.
Bruce, R
1969 Gramática del lacandón. México: Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia.
Coon, J
2010 Complementation in Chol (Mayan): A Theory of Split Ergativity. PhD dissertation, MIT.
Croft, W
1991 Syntactic Categories and Grammatical Relations. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.
Danziger, E
1996 Split intransitivity and active-inactive patterning in Mopan Maya.
International Journal of American Linguistics 62(4): 379–414.
England, N
1992 Autonomía de los idiomas mayas: Historia e identidad. Guatemala: Cholsamaj.
Gutiérrez Sánchez, P
2004 Las clases de verbos intransitivos y el alineamiento agentivo en el Chol de Tila, Chiapas. MA dissertation, CIESAS, Mexico.
Gutiérrez Sánchez, P. & Zavala Maldonado, R
2005 Chol and Chontal: Two Mayan languages of the agentive type. Paper presented at The
Typology of
Stative-Active Languages
. Leipzig: Max-Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
Haviland, J
1994 “Te xa setel xulem” (The buzzards were circling): Categories of verbal roots in (Zinacantec) Tzotil.
Linguistics 32: 691–741.
Heine, B. & Kuteva, T
2002 World Lexicon on Grammaticalization. Cambridge: CUP.
Hofling, C
1991 Itzá Maya Texts. Salt Lake City UT: University of Utah Press.
Hofling, C
2000 Itzaj Maya Grammar. Salt Lake City UT: University of Utah Press.
Justeson, J., Norman, W., Campbell, L. & Kaufman, T
1985 The Foreign Impact on Lowland Mayan Language and Script. New Orleans LO: Middle American Research Institute, Tulane University.
Kaufman, T
1971 Tzeltal Phonology and Morphology. Berkeley CA: University of California publications in linguistics.
Kaufman, T
1976 Archeological and linguistic correlations in Mayaland and associated areas of Meso-America.
World Archeology 8: 101–118.
Kaufman, T
1990 Algunos rasgos estructurales de los idiomas mayances con referencia especial al k’iche. In
Lecturas sobre la lingüística maya,
N. England &
S. Elliot (eds), 9–114. La Antigua, Guatemala: Centro de Investigaciones Regionales de Mesoamérica.
Knowles-Berry, S
1984 A Descriptive Grammar of Chontal Maya, San Carlos Dialect. PhD dissertation, Tulane University, New Orleans.
Langacker, R
1977 Syntactic reanalysis. In
Mechanisms of Syntactic Change,
C. Li (ed.), 57–139. Austin TX: University of Texas Press.
Larsen, T. & Norman, W
1979 Correlates of ergativity in Mayan grammar. In
Ergativity: Toward a Theory of Grammatical Relations,
F. Plank (ed.), 347–370. London: Academic Press.
Lehmann, C
1993 Predicate classes in Yucatec Maya.
Función 13–14: 195–272.
Leonard, J.L., Gendrot, C. & Polian, G
2011 Voyelles réarticulées en tseltal: Pertinence d'une approche dialectologique et expérimentale pour la typologie phonologique.
Bulletin de la Société de Linguistique de Paris CVI (1): 395–449.
Lois, X
2011 Roots and patterns in Yucatecan languages. In
Proceedings of Formal Approaches to Mayan Linguistics [
MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 63],
K. Shklovksy,
P. Mateo Pedro &
J. Coon (eds), 147–169. Cambridge MA: MITWPL.
Lois, X. & Vapnarsky, V
2003 Polyvalence of Root Classes in Yukatekan Mayan Languages [
Studies in Native American Linguistics 47]. Munich: Lincom.
Lois, X. & Vapnarsky, V
2006 Root indeterminacy and polyvalence in Yukatekan Mayan languages. In
Lexical Categories and Root Classes in Amerindian Languages,
X. Lois &
V. Vapnarsky (eds), 69–115. Bern: Peter Lang.
Lois, X., Vapnarsky, V., Fréger, C. & Atran, S
2010 Itza’ Memorias Mayas. Mérida, México: Universidad Autónoma de México.
Lopéz Sántiz, A. del C
2005 Palabras Tejidas. Jalbil k’opetik. Tuxtla Gutierrez: Gobierno del Estado de Chiapas.
Lucy, J
1994 The role of semantic value in lexical comparison: Motion and position roots in Yucatec maya.
Linguistics 32: 623–656.
Marantz, A
1997 No escape from syntax: Don’t try morphological analysis in the privacy of your own lexicon. In
Proceedings of the 21th Annual Penn Linguistics Colloquium [
Penn Working Papers in Linguistics 4:2],
A. Dimitriadis,
L. Siegel,
C. Surek-Clark &
A. Williams (eds), 201–225. Philadelphia PA: University of Pennsilvania.
Monod-Becquelin, A
1997 Parlons tzeltal, une langue Maya du Mexique. Paris: L’Harmattan.
Osorio May, J. del C
2005 Análisis de la morfología verbal del Yokot’an, “Chontal” del Poblado de Tecoluta, Nacajuca, Tabasco. MA dissertation, CIESAS, Mexico.
Polian, G
2006 Éléments de grammaire du tseltal. Une langue maya du Mexique. Paris: L’Harmattan.
Polian, G. & Leonard, J.L
2009 La morphologie dans ALTO (Atlas Linguistique du Tseltal Occidental). Réseau dialectal et systèmes à décideurs multiples.
Géolinguistique 11: 149–201.
Polian, G
2013a Infinitivos transitivos: Innovaciones del Tseltal en la familia Maya. In
Clases léxicas, posesión y cláusulas complejas en lenguas de Mesoamérica,
E. Palancar &
R. Zavala (eds), 339–380. México: CIESAS.
Polian, G
2013b Gramática del tseltal de Oxchuc. Mexico: CIESAS.
Pye, C
2011 Mayan stative predication. In
Proceedings of Formal Approaches to Mayan Linguistics [
MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 63],
K. Shklovksy,
P. Mateo Pedro &
J. Coon (eds), 191–207. Cambridge MA: MITWPL.
Quizar, R. & Knowles-Berry, S
1988 Ergativity in the Cholan languages.
International Journal of American Linguistics 54(1): 73–85.
Quizar, R. & Knowles-Berry, S
1990 Ergatividad en los idiomas ch’oles. In
Lecturas sobre la lingüística maya,
N. England &
S.E. Elliott (eds), 301–318. Guatemala: Centro de Investigaciones Regionales de Mesoamérica.
Robertson, J
1980 The Structure of Pronoun Incorporation in the Mayan Verbal Complex. New York NY: Garland.
Robertson. J
1992 The History of Tense/Aspect/Mood/Voice in the Mayan Verbal Complex. Austin TX: University of Texan Press.
Robertson, J
1998 A Ch'olti'an Explanation for Ch'orti'an Grammar: A Postlude to the Language of the Classic Maya.
Mayab 11: 5–11.
Robles Uribe, C
1966 La dialectología tzeltal y el diccionario compacto. México: Instituto Nacional de Antropología.
Schumann, O
1997 Introducción al Maya Mopán. México DF: Instituto de Investigaciones Antropológicas, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.
Shklovsky, K
2005 Person Marking in Petalcingo Tseltal. PhD dissertation, Reed College.
Ulrich. M., Ulrich, R. & Peck, C
1986 Mopan Mayan Verbs. Guatemala: Instituto Linguístico de Verano.
Van Valin Jr., R.D. & LaPolla, R.J
1997 Syntax: Structure, Meaning, and Function. Cambridge: CUP.
Vapnarsky, V
1999 Expressions et conceptions de la temporalité chez les Mayas Yucatèques du Quintana Roo. PhD dissertation, University of Paris 10, Nanterre.
Vapnarsky, V. & Lois, X
2009 Morphosyntactic and semantic issues on polycategoriality in Yucatecan Mayan languages. Talk presented at
ALT 8
, Berkely, July.
Vapnarsky, V
2013 Is Yucatec an omnipredicative language? Predication, the copula and focus constructions.
Language Typology and Universals 66: 40–86.
Vázquez Álvarez, J
2002 Morfología del verbo de la lengua chol de Tila Chiapas. MA dissertation, CIESAS, México.
Wisdom, C
1950 Materials on the Chorti Languages [
Microfilm of the Collection Manuscripts on Middle American Cultural Anthropology 28]. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Library.
Zavala, R
2007 The agentive alignment pattern in Cholan and K’ichean (Mayan). Paper presented in the
AALLED conference
, Lyon, France, February.
Cited by (2)
Cited by 2 other publications
Firmino-Castillo, María Regina, Daniel Fernando Guarcax González & TOHIL / Fidel Brito Bernal
2023.
Destellos entre mundos y cuerpos: .
Revista Brasileira de Estudos em Dança 1:1
► pp. 318 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 24 june 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.