The ‘Biolinguistics’ program seeks to establish specific neuroanatomical models corresponding to the representations and operations characterizing the species-specific language faculty in human beings. Yet after decades of research, no neural structures corresponding to specific linguistic structures, rules, constraints or principles have ever been identified. A key to biolinguistics’ failure is, I suggest, its long-term adherence to two dubious assumptions: (i) a kind of literalism in envisaging the relationship between neural anatomy and linguistic representations, reflecting a seriously misconstrual of Marr’s (1982) tripartite division of cognition, and (ii) a view of such representations as objects fundamentally different from other components of human cognitive capacity. (ii) rests on the premise that phrase markers are the optimal formal representation of natural language sentences, despite major empirical difficulties that syntactic accounts based hierarchical phrase structure face in handling a wide variety of grammatical patterns, including non-canonical coordinations and ellipsis constructions. In contrast, proof-theoretic approaches such as type-logical grammar do not face these difficulties, and their foundational assumptions link language to the higher-order cognitive functions supporting deductive reasoning. This conclusion suggests a promising alternative to the current, essentially result-free ‘Biolinguistic’ paradigm.
Anderson, Stephen R. & Lightfoot, David. 2002. The Language Organ: Linguistics as Cognitive Physiology. Cambridge: CUP.
Anderson, Stephen R. & Lightfoot, David. 2006. Biology and language: A response to Everett (2005). Journal of Linguistics 42: 377–383.
Ardila, Alfredo, Bernal, Byron & Rosselli, Monica. 2016. How localized are language brain areas? A review of Brodmann areas’ involvement in oral language. Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology 31(1):112–122.
Behme, Christina. 2012. The essence of Postal’s criticism: A short reply to Ulfsbjorninn (2012). <[URL]>
Behme, Christina. 2013. Biolinguistic platonism remains an oxymoron. <[URL]>
Behme, Christina. 2014. A galilean science of language. Journal of Linguistics 51: 671–704.
Chomsky, Noam. 1976. On the nature of language. In Origins and Evolution of Language and Speech, Steven R. Harnad, Horst D. Steklis & Jane Lancaster (eds). Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 280: 46–57.
Chomsky, Noam. 1981. Lectures on Government and Binding. Dordrecht: Foris.
Chomsky, Noam. 1983. Some conceptual shifts in the study of language. In How Many Questions? Essays in Honor of Sidney Morgenbesser, Leigh S. Cauman, Isaac Levi, Charles D. Parsons & Robert Schwartz (eds), 154–169. Indianapolis IN: Hackett.
Chomsky, Noam. 1986. Barriers. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Chomsky, Noam. 2012. The Science of Language. Cambridge: CUP.
Citko, Barbara. 2000. Parallel Merge and the Syntax of Free Relatives. PhD dissertation, SUNY.
de Groote, Philippe. 2001. Towards abstract categorial grammars. In Association for Computational Linguistics, 39th Annual Meeting and 10th Conference of the European Chapter, 148–155.
de Vries, Mark. 2009. On multidominance and linearization. Biolinguistics 3(4):344–403.
Embick, David & Poeppel, David. 2015. Towards a computational(ist) neurobiology of language: Correlational, integrated and explanatory neurolinguistics. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 30: 357–366.
Everett, Daniel L.2001. Discussion: on nonobjects of linguistic study. Linguist List vol. 12, no. i8i6. <[URL]>
Everett, Daniel. 2005. Biology and language: A consideration of alternatives. Journal of Linguistics 41:157–175.
Everett, Daniel. 2006. Biology and language: Response to Anderson & Lightfoot. Journal of Linguistics 42(2): 385–393.
Fodor, Jerry. 1975. The Language of Thought. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Fodor, Jerry. 1983. The Modularity of Mind. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Hofmeister, Philip, Staum Casasanto, Laura & Sag, Ivan A.2012. Misapplying working memory tests: A reductio ad absurdum. Language 88: 408–409.
Hofmeister, Philip, Staum Casasanto, Laura & Sag, Ivan A.2013a. Islands in the grammar? Standards of evidence. In Experimental Syntax and Island Effects, Jon Sprouse & Norbert Hornstein (eds), 42–63. Cambridge: CUP.
Hofmeister, Philip, Arnon, Inbal, Jaeger, T. Florian, Sag, Ivan & Snider, Neal. 2013b. The source ambiguity problem: Distinguishing the effects of grammar and processing on acceptability judgments. Language and Cognitive Processes 28: 48–87.
Hofmeister, Philip & Sag, Ivan A.2010. Cognitive constraints and island effects. Language 86(2): 366–415.
Jacobson, Pauline. 2007. Direct compositionality and variable-free semantics: The case of “Principle B” effects. In Direct Compositionality, Chris Barker & Pauline Jacobson (eds.), 191–236. Oxford: OUP.
Johnson, Kyle. 2000. Few dogs eat Whiskas or cats Alpo. In University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers, vol. 23, Kiyomi Kusumoto & Elisabeth Villalta (eds), 47–60. Amherst MA: GLSA.
Johnson, Kyle. 2009. Gapping is not (VP-) ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 40(2): 289–328.
Julesz, Bela & Caelli, Terry. 1979. On the limits of Fourier decompositions in visual texture perception. Perception 8: 69–73.
Kandybowicz, Jason. 2006. Comp-trace effects explained away. In Proceedings of WCCFL 25, 220–228. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Kandybowicz, Jason. 2009. Embracing edges: Syntactic and phono-syntactic edge sensitivity in nupe. NLLT 27: 305–344.
Katz, Jerrold J. & Postal, Paul M.. 1991. Realism vs. conceptualism in linguistics. Linguistics and Philosophy 14: 515–554.
Katz, Jerrold J.1981. Language and Other Abstract Objects. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Littlefield.
Kehler, Andrew. 2002. Coherence, Reference and the Theory of Grammar. Stanford CA: CSLI.
Kluender, Robert. 1998. On the distinction between strong and weak islands: A processing perspective. In The Limits of Syntax (Syntax and Semantics 29), Peter Culicover & Louise McNally (eds), 241–279. San Diego CA: Academic Press.
Kubota, Yusuke. 2015. Nonconstituent coordination in Japanese as constituent coordination: An analysis in Hybrid Type-Logical Categorial Grammar. Linguistic Inquiry 46(1):1–42.
Kubota, Yusuke & Lee, Jungmee. 2015. The Coordinate Structure Constraint as a discourse oriented principle: Further evidence from Japanese and Korean. Language 91(3): 642–675.
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2014. Scope anomaly of gapping. In Proceedings of NELS 44, 247–260. Amherst MA: GLSA.
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2015. Against ellipsis: Arguments for the direct licensing of ‘non-canonical’ coordinations. Linguistics and Philosophy 38(6): 521–576.
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2016a. Gapping as hypothetical reasoning. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 34(1):107–156. .
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2016b. The syntax-semantics interface of ‘respective’ predication: A unified analysis in Hybrid Type-Logical Categorial Grammar. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 34 (3): 911–973.
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2017a. Pseudogapping as pseudo-VP ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 48(2): 213–257.
Kubota, Yusuke & Levine, Robert. 2017b. Scope parallelism in coordination in Dependent Type Semantics. In New Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, Mihoko Otake, Setsuya Kurahashi, Yuiko Ota, Ken Satoh & Daisuke Bekki (eds.), 79–92. Berlin: Springer.
Lambek, Joachim. 1958. The mathematics of sentence structure. American Mathematical Monthly 65(3):154–170.
Leipnik, Roy B.1960. The extended entropy uncertainty principle. Information and Control 3(1):18–25.
Levine, Robert. 2011. Linerarization and its discontents. In The Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar, Stefan Müller (ed.), 126–146. Stanford CA: CSLI.
Macnamara, John. 1986. A Border Dispute: the Place of Logic in Psychology. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Marr, David. 1982. Vision. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Marr, David & Hildreth, Ellen. 1980. Theory of edge detection. Proceedings of the Royal Society 207:187–217.
Martins, Pedro Tiago & Boeckx, Cedric. 2016. What we talk about when we talk about biolinguistics. Linguistics Vanguard 2(1). <[URL]>
McCawley, James D.1982. Parentheticals and discontinuous constituent structure. Linguistic Inquiry 13(1): 91–106.
Monti, Martin M., Parsons, Lawrence & Osherson, Daniel N.2009. The boundaries of language and thought in deductive inference. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106: 12554–12559.
Moot, Richard. To appear. Hybrid type-logical grammars, first-order linear logic and the descriptive inadequacy of Lambda grammars. Journal of Logics and their Applications (International Federation of Computational Logic).
Muskens, Reinhard. 2003. Language, lambdas, and logic. In Resource Sensitivity in Binding and Anaphora, Geert-Jan Kruijff & Richard Oehrle (eds), 23–54. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Nediger, Will. 2015. Focus and Condition C. In Proceedings of the 32nd West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, Ulrike Steindl, Thomas Borer, Huilin Fang, Alfredo García Pardo, Peter Guekguezian, Brian Hsu, Charlie O’Hara & Iris Chuoying Ouyang (eds), 296–302. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.
Newmeyer, Frederick J.2003. Review article on On Nature and Language by Noam Chomsky, The Language Organ: Linguistics as Cognitive Psychology by Stephen Anderson and David Lightfoot, and Language in a Darwinian Perspective by B. H. Bichakjian. Language 79: 583–599.
Newmeyer, Frederick J.2005. Possible and Probable Languages: A Generative Perspective on Linguistics. Oxford: OUP.
Newmeyer, Frederick J.2016. Nonsyntactic explanations of island constraints. Annual Review of Linguistics 2: 187–210.
Oehrle, Richard T.1987. Boolean properties in the analysis of gapping. In Discontinuous Constituency (Syntax and Semantics 20), Geoffrey J. Huck & Almerindo E. Ojeda (eds), 203–240. New York NY: Academic Press.
Oehrle, Richard T.1994. Term-labeled categorial type systems. Linguistics and Philosophy 17(6):633–678.
Partee, Barbara & Rooth, Mats. 1983. Generalized conjunction and type ambiguity. In Meaning, Use, and Interpretation of Language, Rainer Bäuerle, Christoph Schwarze & Arnim von Stechow (eds), 361–383. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Pollard, Carl & Sag, Ivan A.1992. Anaphors in English and the scope of binding theory. Linguistic Inquiry 23(2): 261–303.
Pollard, Carl & Sag, Ivan A.1994. Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar. Studies in Contemporary Linguistics. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.
Postal, Paul M.. 2009. The incoherence of Chomsky’s ‘biolinguistic’ ontology. Biolinguistics 3(1):247–266.
Reverberi, Carlo, Cherubini, Paolo, Rapisarda, Attilio, Rigamonti, Elisa, Caltagirone, Carlo, Frackowiak, Richard S. J., Macaluso, Emiliano & Paulesu, Eraldo. 2007. Neural basis of generation of conclusions in elementary deduction. NeuroImage 38: 752–762.
Rips, Lance J.1994. The Psychology of Proof. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Ross, John Robert. 1967. Constraints on Variables in Syntax. PhD dissertation, MIT. Reproduced by the Indiana University Linguistics Club.
Safir, Kenneth. 2004. The Syntax of Anaphora. Oxford: OUP.
Siegel, Muffy E. A.1984. Gapping and interpretation. Linguistic Inquiry 15(3): 523–530.
Soames, Scott. 1984. Linguistics and psychology. Linguistics and Philosophy 7:155–179.
Tettamanti, Marco, Rotondi, Irene, Perani, Daniella, Scotti, Giuseppe, Fazio, Ferrucio, Cappa, Stefano F. & Moro, Andrea. 2009. Syntax without language: neurobiological evidence for cross-domain syntactic computations. Cortex 45:825–838.
Toosarvandani, Maziar. 2013. Gapping is low coordination (plus VP-ellipsis): A reply to Johnson. Ms, MIT.
Westheimer, Gerald. 2001. The Fourier theory of vision. Perception 30: 531–541.
Cited by (4)
Cited by four other publications
Buder-Gröndahl, Tommi
2023. The ambiguity of BERTology: what do large language models represent?. Synthese 203:1
Nefdt, Ryan M.
2023. Biolinguistics and biological systems: a complex systems analysis of language. Biology & Philosophy 38:2
Forker, Diana
2021. General linguistics and the nature of human language. Theoretical Linguistics 47:1-2 ► pp. 61 ff.
Mondal, Prakash
2020. Introduction. In Language, Biology and Cognition, ► pp. 1 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 27 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.