Single-parameter and parameter combination errors in L2 productions of Swiss German Sign Language
Sarah Ebling | University of Zurich University of Zurich
Katja Tissi | University of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), ZurichUniversity of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), Zurich
Sandra Sidler-Miserez | University of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), ZurichUniversity of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), Zurich
Cheryl Schlumpf | University of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), ZurichUniversity of Teacher Education in Special Needs (HfH), Zurich
Penny Boyes Braem | Center for Sign Language Research BaselCenter for Sign Language Research Basel
This article presents a study of errors made by hearing adult L2 learners of Swiss German Sign Language
(Deutschschweizerische Gebärdensprache, DSGS). As part of a statistical analysis of single-parameter errors,
movement was found to be the parameter most susceptible to errors, followed by location, orientation, and handshape. An analysis
of production errors with respect to combinations of manual parameters was also conducted, something that previously has not been
undertaken. The parameter combination most frequently involved in errors was movement with location. Possible aspects contributing
to the higher error rate for movement are suggested, among which are the inherent complexity of the movement parameter. Finally,
the article discusses factors influencing the judgment of errors.
Keywords: phonological parameters, parameter errors, criteria for judging errors, L2 learning, Swiss German Sign Language
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Previous work
- 2.1Accuracy of production of phonological parameters by L2 signers
- 2.2Definitions of error
- 2.2.1Errors in sign languages
- 2.2.2Errors in spoken languages
- 2.3Erroneous features of phonological parameters by L2 signers
- 3.Method
- 3.1Participant recruitment
- 3.2Selection of lexical items
- 3.3Preparation of stimulus materials
- 3.4Testing procedure
- 3.5Transcription and annotation
- 3.5.1Definition of error
- 3.5.2Category of sign produced and joint confidence in the decision
- 3.5.3Identification of parameters contributing to phonological errors
- 3.6Statistical analyses
- 3.6.1Single-parameter errors
- 3.6.2Parameter combination errors
- 4.Results
- 4.1Statistical analyses of results
- 4.1.1Single-parameter errors
- 4.1.2Parameter combination errors
- 4.1.3Degree of contribution of each parameter to the judgment of error
- 4.2Movement errors
- 4.2.1Phonological features involved in movement errors
- 4.2.2Difficulties of the movement parameter
- 4.2.2.1Complexity of the movement parameter
- 4.2.2.2Especially marked movements
- 4.2.2.3Direction of horizontal circling movements
- 4.2.2.4L2 learners’ tendency to proximalize the movement
- 4.3Movement+location errors
- 4.3.1Perceptual salience
- 4.3.2Adding or dropping body contact
- 4.4Other factors influencing results
- 4.4.1Judging L1 vs. L2 productions
- 4.4.2Breadth of knowledge of lexical items on the part of raters
- 4.4.3Degree of experience with teaching and/or researching sign language
- 4.1Statistical analyses of results
- 5.Concluding remarks and outlook
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
Published online: 02 July 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.19002.ebl
https://doi.org/10.1075/sll.19002.ebl
References
Arendsen, Jeroen
Baus, Cristina, Eva Gutiérrez & Manuel Carreiras
Bochner, Joseph, Karen Christie & Peter Hauser
Boyes Braem, Penny
Chaudron, Craig
Chen Pichler, Deborah
Chen Pichler, Deborah & Elena Koulidobrova
Chen Pichler, Deborah, Martin Watkins, Danica Dicus & Sadi Dudley
Conlin, Kimberly, Gene R. Mirus, Claude Mauk & Richard P. Meier
Cormier, Kearsy, Jordan Fenlon, Trevor Johnston, Ramas Rentelis, Adam Schembri, Katherine Rowley, Robert Adam, & Bencie Woll
2012 From Corpus to Lexical Database to Online Dictionary: Issues in Annotation of the BSL Corpus and the Development of BSL Signbank. Proceedings of the 5th LREC Workshop on the Representation and Processing of Sign Languages, Istanbul, Turkey. 7–12.
Cull, Amber
Council of Europe
Dye, Matthew W. G. & Shui-I Shih
Ebling, Sarah, Necati Cihan Camgöz, Penny Boyes Braem, Katja Tissi, Sandra Sidler-Miserez, Stephanie Stoll, Simon Hadfield, Tobias Haug, Richard Bowden, Sandrine Tornay, Marzieh Razavi & Mathew Magimai-Doss
Efthimiou, Eleni, Stavroula-Evita Fotinea, Christian Vogler, Thomas Hanke, John Glauert, Richard Bowden, Annelies Braffort, Christophe Collect, Petros Maragos & Jérémie Segouat
Gries, Stefan
Hall, Matthew L., Victor S. Ferreira & Rachel I. Mayberry
Hanke, Thomas
Hanke, Thomas & Jakob Storz
Hildebrandt, Ursula & David Corina
Lupton, Linda & Howard Zelaznik
Marentette, Paula F. & Rachel I. Mayberry
Mayberry, Rachel I., Matthew L. Hall & Meghan Zvaigzne
Meier, Richard, Claude Mauk, Gene Mirus & Kimberly E. Conlin
Mirus, Gene, Christian Rathmann & Richard P. Meier
Morford, Jill P. & Martina L. Carlson
Morgan, Gary, Sarah Barrett-Jones & Helen Stoneham
Napoli, Donna Jo, Nathan C. Sanders & Rebecca Wright
Newell, Karl M. & P. Vernon McDonald
Ochs, Elinor
Ortega, Gerardo
Ortega, Gerardo & Gary Morgan
Prillwitz, Siegmund, Renata Leven, Horst Zienert, Thomas Hanke & Jan Henning
Rosen, Russell S.
Sanders, Nathan & Donna Jo Napoli
Schlehofer, Deirdre & Isaiah J. Tyler
Siedlecki, Theodore Jr. & John D. Bonvillian
Vinson, David P., Kearsy Cormier, Tanja Denmark, Adam Schembri & Gabriella Vigliocco
Williams, Joshua & Sharlene Newman