Against the addressee of speech – Recipient metaphor
Evidence from East Caucasian
In Standard Average European (SAE), addressees of speech verbs are marked with dative or, in languages lacking cases, with dative-like prepositions. This merger is commonly explained through a metaphor: the information transferred in a speech act is said to be construed as the object being transferred, or Theme, and the addressee as its Recipient. This status of the addressee as a derived concept, a metaphor of the Recipient, and its dative marking in many languages rather than in SAE alone, is the reason why the addressee is usually not considered to be a separate semantic role. Based on data from East Caucasian languages that use different marking for Recipients and addressees of speech, I argue that speech addressees constitute a separate semantic role, also an animate Goal, but not a metaphor of the Recipient. Focusing on case marking assigned by the main speech verb, speech acts are shown to be construed in East Caucasian as spatial configurations: the crucial component is their directedness towards the addressee. In the conclusion, I come back to SAE and question the status of the dative addressees. Taking into account that the dative often develops from lative markers, it is suggested that, in the languages with dative addressees, one should also consider an alternative to the conventional explanation: merging the Recipient and the addressee in one marking may result not from a metaphorical extension but from formal under-specification of two different animate Goals. Keywords: semantic roles; speech verbs; case functions; metaphor; dative; allative; Recipient; Goal; East Caucasian languages
References
Arkhipov, Alexandre, Daniel, Michael, Kibrik, Aleksandr & Sandro, Kodzasov
Unpublished.
Archi Electronic Corpus. An electronic collection of glossed texts. Partly available at
[URL].
Arkhipov, Alexandre, Daniel, Michael, Kibrik, Aleksandr & Sandro, Kodzasov
Unpublished.
Khinalug Electronic Corpus. Partly available at
[URL].
Authier, Gilles
2009 Grammaire Kryz, langue caucasique d’Azerbaïdjan, dialecte d’Alik. Leuven: Peeters.
van den Berg, Helma
1995 A Grammar of Hunzib. Munich: Lincom.
Bokarev, Anatolij
1949 Očerki grammatiki čamalinskogo jazyka. Moscow – Leningrad: AN SSSR.
Bokarev, Anatolij
1949 Sintaksis avarskogo jazyka. Moscow – Leningrad: AN SSSR.
Charachidze, Georges
1981 Grammaire de la langue avar. Langue du Caucase Nord-Est. Paris: Dunod.
Comrie, Bernard
1981 Language Universals and Linguistic Typology: Syntax and Morphology. Oxford: Blackwell & Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Creissels, Denis
A Grammar of Akhvakh. Ms.
Creissels, Denis
In preparation.
Functive phrases in typological and diachronic perspective.
Cysouw, Michael & Diana, Forker
2009 Reconstruction of morphosyntactic function: Nonspatial usage of spatial case marking in Tsezic.
Language 85(3): 588–617.
Dąbrowska, Ewa
1997 Cognitive Semantics and the Polish Dative. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Daniel, Michael & Yuri, Lander
2011 The Caucasian languages. In
Bernd Kortmann &
Johan van der Auwera (eds.),
The Languages and Linguistics of Europe: A Comprehensive Guide, 125–158. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Daniel, Michael & Dmitri, Ganenkov
2009 Case marking in Daghestanian. In
Andrej Malchukov &
Andrew Spencer (eds.),
Handbook of Case, 668–685. Oxford: OUP.
Daniel, Michael, Khalilova, Zaira & Zarina, Molochieva
2010 Ditransitive constructions in East Caucasian. In
Andrej Malchukov,
Martin Haspelmath &
Bernard Comrie (eds.),
Studies in Ditransitive Constructions: A Comprehensive Handbook, 277–315. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Dowty, David R
1991 Thematic proto-roles and argument selection.
Language 67: 547–619.
Dryer, Matthew S
1986 Primary objects, secondary objects, and antidative.
Language 62: 808–845.
[URL] DOI:
Fillmore, Charles J
1968 The case for case. In
Emmon Bach &
Robert T. Harms (eds.),
Universals in Linguistic Theory, 1–88. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Forker, Diana
2013 A Grammar of Hinuq. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Ganenkov, Dmitri, Lander, Yuri & Timur, Maisak
Unpublished.
Udi Electronic Corpus. An electronic collection of glossed texts.
Ganenkov, Dmitri, Maisak, Timur & Solmaz, Merdanova
Unpublished.
Agul Electronic Corpus. An electronic collection of glossed texts.
Ganenkov, Dmitry
2010 Topological relations in Daghestanian languages: An overview.
Linguistics 48(5): 1011–1041.
Goldberg, Adele E
1995 A Construction Grammar Approach to Argument Structure. Chicago: UCP.
Gudava, Togo E
1967 Botlixskij jazyk. In Jazyki narodov SSSR, Vol. 4: Iberijsko-kavkazskije jazyki, 293–306. Moscow: AN SSSR.
Haspelmath, Martin
1993 A Grammar of Lezgian. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Heine, Bernd & Tania, Kuteva
2002 World Lexicon of Grammaticalization. Cambridge: CUP.
Janda, Laura
1993 A Geography of Case Semantics: The Czech Dative and the Russian Instrumental. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Khalilova, Zaira
2009 A Grammar of Khwarshi. Utrecht: LOT.
Kibrik, Aleksandr & Jakov, Testelets
(eds) 1999 Elementy caxurskogo jazyka v tipologičeskom osveščenii. Moscow: Nasledie.
Kibrik, Aleksandr
(ed.) 1996 Godoberi [
Lincom Studies in Caucasian Linguistics 02] Munich: Lincom.
Kibrik, Aleksandr, Kazenin, Konstantin, Ljutikova, Ekaterina & Sergej, Tatevosov
(eds) 2001 Bagvalinskij jazyk: Grammatika, teksty, slovari. Moscow: Nasledie.
Kibrik, Aleksandr, Kodzasov, Sandro & Irina, Olovjannikova
1972 Fragmenty grammatiki xinalugskogo jazyka. Moscow: Moscow State University.
Kibrik, Aleksandr
1977 Opyt strukturnogo opisanija arčinskogo jazyka. Vol. 2. Moscow: Moscow State University.
Kibrik, Aleksandr
2003a Konstanty i peremennyje jazyka. St. Petersburg: Aleteia.
Kibrik, Aleksandr
2003b Nominal inflection galore: Daghestanian, with side glances at Europe and the world. In
Frans Plank (ed.),
Noun Phrase Structure in the Languages of Europe, 37–112. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Levin, Beth & Malka, Rappoport Hovav
2005 Argument Realization. Cambridge: CUP.
Magomedova, Patimat T
2003 Tindinkso-russkij slovarj. Maxačkala: Institute of Language and Literature(Russian Academy of Sciences).
Magometov, Aleksandr
1965 Tabasaranskij jazyk. (Issledovanija i teksty). Tbilisi: Mecniereba.
Magometov, Aleksandr
1982 Megebskij dialect darginskogo jazyka. (Issledovanija i teksty). Tbilisi: Mecniereba.
Makhmudova, Svetlana
2001 Morfologija rutul’skogo jazyka. Moscow: IJa RAN.
Malchukov, Andrej, Hartmann, Iren, Haspelmath, Martin, Comrie, Bernard & Søren, Wichmann
(eds.) In preparation
Valency Classes in the World’s Languages
Malchukov, Andrej, Haspelmath, Martin & Bernard, Comrie
2010 Ditransitive constructions: A typological overview. In
Andrej Malchukov,
Martin Haspelmath &
Bernard Comrie,
Studies in Ditransitive Constructions: Comparative Handbook, 1–64. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Molochieva, Zarina, Witzlack-Makrevich, Alena, Bickel, Balthasar & Johanna, Nichols
Unpublished.
Chechen Pears Stories Collection. Electronic Corpus. University of Leipzig & University of Berkeley.
Musaev, Magomed-Salam
1999 Darginskij jazyk. In Jazyki mira: Kavkazskije jazyki. Moscow: Nauka.
Nichols, Johanna
2011 Ingush Grammar [
UC Publications in Linguistics]. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
Pasquereau, Jérémy
2010 Formes spatiales des noms en karata: Emplois spatiaux et non-spatiaux. Lyon: University of Lyon dissertation(Memoire de master 1).
Salimov, Hangerej S
2010 Gagatlinskij govor andijskogo jazyka. Maxačkala: Institute of Language and Literature(Russian Academy of Sciences).
Sumbatova, Nina & Rasul, Mutalov
2003 A Grammar of Icari Dargwa [
Languages of the World, Materials 92]. Munich: Lincom.
Talibov, Bukar
2007 Buduxskij jazyk. Moscow: Academia.
Testelets, Jakov
1980 Imennyje lokativnyje formy v dagestanskix jazykax. Moscow: Moscow State University.
Van Valin, Robert
2005 Exploring the Syntax-semantic Interface. Cambridge: CUP.
Van Valin Jr., Robert D. & Randy J. LaPolla
1997 Syntax: Structure, Meaning, and Function. Cambridge: CUP.
Žirkov, Lev
1955 Lakskij jazyk: Fonetika i morfologija. Moscow: AN SSSR.
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
TOYOTA, JUNICHI
2017.
<i>Perspectives on Semantic Roles</i>.
ENGLISH LINGUISTICS 33:2
► pp. 567 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 19 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.