Chapter 6
Comparative concepts are not a different kind of thing
This contribution challenges the by now established notion of comparative concepts; in particular, it can be read as a (delayed) response to Haspelmath (2010). Like Haspelmath’s original paper, the present one is theoretical in essence, with examples used primarily for illustration. My main point is that Haspelmath’s comparative concepts are, despite his claims to the contrary, simply crosslinguistic categories. This point has been made before; however, I offer two new ingredients to the argument: first, an explicit definition of the crucial term instantiation, allowing, among other things, a reaction to Haspelmath’s (2018b) newest defence of comparative concepts, and second, an alternative approach involving multiple monotonic inheritance. The contribution as a whole, though being theoretical, strives to argue as framework-neutrally as possible; in particular I remain agnostic about the existence and nature of Universal Grammar in any sense.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.A critical close reading of Haspelmath (2010a)
- 2.1Short summary of Haspelmath (2010a)
- 2.2Discussion of Haspelmath (2010a)
- 2.2.1The core arguments
- 2.2.2Haspelmath’s suggestions for concrete comparative concepts
- 3.An alternative: Monotonic, multiple inheritance
- 3.1Background
- 3.2Blueprint
- 3.3Implementation
- 3.3.1A guided tour through Figure 11
- 3.3.2Beyond Figure 11
- 4.Conclusion and outlook
-
Acknowledgments
-
Notes
-
References
References (64)
Armstrong, David M.
2004 How do particulars stand to universals?
In
Oxford Studies in Metaphysics 1,
Dean W.
Zimmerman
(ed.), 139–154. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Biggs, Bruce
1961 The structure of New Zealand Maaori.
Anthropological Linguistics
3(3): 1–54.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Brown, Cecil H.
2013 Hand and arm. In
The World Atlas of Language Structures Online,
Matthew S.
Dryer &
Martin
Haspelmath
(eds). Leipzig: MPI for Evolutionary Anthropology.
[URL] (18 December 2018).
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Brown, Dunstan & Hippisley, Andrew
2012 Network Morphology. A Defaults-based Theory of Word Structure [
Cambridge Studies in Linguistics 133]. Cambridge: CUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Chomsky, Noam
1957 Syntactic Structures [
Janua Linguarum 4]. The Hague: Mouton.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Clements, George N.
1985 The geometry of phonological features.
Phonology Yearbook
2: 225–252.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Croft, William
2001 Radical Construction Grammar. Syntactic Theory in Typological Perspective. Oxford: OUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Croft, William
2005 Word classes, parts of speech, and syntactic argumentation.
Linguistic Typology
9(3): 431–441.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Culicover, Peter W.
1999 Syntactic Nuts. Hard Cases, Syntactic Theory, and Language Acquisition [
Foundations of Syntax 1]. Oxford: OUP.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Daelemans, Walter, Gerald, Gazdar & De Smedt, Koenraad
1992 Inheritance in natural language processing.
Computational Linguistics
18(2): 205–218.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Dahl, Östen
2016 Thoughts on language-specific and crosslinguistic entities.
Linguistic Typology
20(2): 427–437.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Dryer, Matthew S.
2005 Order of adjective and noun. In
The World Atlas of Language Structures,
Martin
Haspelmath,
Matthew S.
Dryer,
David
Gil &
Bernard
Comrie
(eds), 354–357. Oxford: OUP.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Dryer, Matthew S.
2013 Order of adjective and noun. In
The World Atlas of Language Structures Online,
Matthew S.
Dryer &
Martin
Haspelmath
(eds). Leipzig: MPI for Evolutionary Anthropology.
[URL] (16 January 2019).
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Elbert, Samuel H. & Pukui, Mary Kawena
1979 Hawaiian Grammar. Honolulu HI: The University Press of Hawaii.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Gair, James W.
1970 Colloquial Sinhalese Clause Structures [
Janua Linguarum; Series Practica 83]. The Hague: Mouton.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Gerner, Matthias & Bisang, Walter
2010 Social-deixis classifiers in Weining Ahmao. In
Rara & Rarissima. Documenting the Fringes of Linguistic Diversity [
Empirical Approaches to Language Typology 46],
Jan
Wohlgemuth &
Michael
Cysouw
(eds), 75–94. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Gil, David
2013 Riau Indonesian. A language without nouns and verbs. In
Flexible Word Classes. Typological Studies of Underspecified Parts of Speech,
Jan
Rijkhoff &
Eva
van Lier
(eds), 89–130. Oxford: OUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Glottolog
[URL] (18 December 2018).
Goddard, Cliff
1982 Case systems and case marking in Australian languages. A new interpretation.
Australian Journal of Linguistics
2(2): 167–196.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Goddard, Cliff
1985 A Grammar of Yankunytjatjara. Alice Springs: Institute for Aboriginal Development.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Goddard, Cliff & Wierzbicka, Anna
Gross, Maurice
1989 On the failure of Generative Grammar.
Language
55(4): 859–885.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Halle, Morris, Vaux, Bert & Wolfe, Andrew
2000 On feature spreading and the representation of place of articulation.
Linguistic Inquiry
31(3): 387–444.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Harley, Heidi & Ritter, Elizabeth
Haspelmath, Martin
2010a Comparative concepts and descriptive categories in crosslinguistic studies.
Language
86(3): 663–687.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Haspelmath, Martin
2010b The interplay between comparative concepts and descriptive categories (Reply to Newmeyer).
Language
86(3): 696–699.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Haspelmath, Martin
2011 The indeterminacy of word segmentation and the nature of morphology and syntax.
Folia Linguistica
45(1): 31–80.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Haspelmath, Martin
2018a Facing the challenge of general linguistics when nature doesn’t help us.
Diversity Linguistics Comment of 18 February.
[URL] (7 February 2019).
Haspelmath, Martin
2018b How comparative concepts and descriptive linguistic categories are different. In
Aspects of Linguistic Variation,
Daniël
Van Olmen,
Tanja
Mortelmans &
Frank
Brisard
(eds), 83–114. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Hengeveld, Kees
1992 Non-verbal Predication. Theory, Typology, Diachrony [
Functional Grammar Series 15]. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Hengeveld, Kees
2013 Parts-of-speech systems as a basic typological determinant. In
Flexible Word Classes. Typological Studies of Underspecified Parts of Speech,
Jan
Rijkhoff &
Eva
van Lier
(eds), 31–55. Oxford: OUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Kaplan, Ronald M.
2003 Syntax. In
The Oxford Handbook of Computational Linguistics,
Ruslan
Mitkov
(ed.), 70–90. Oxford: OUP.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Karlsson, Fred
2015 Finnish. An Essential Grammar [
Routledge Essential Grammars], 3rd edn. London: Routledge.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Kim, Jong-Bok
2016 The Syntactic Structures of Korean. A Construction Grammar Perspective. Cambridge: CUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Klein, Wolfgang
1994 Time in Language [
Germanic Linguistics]. London: Routledge.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Koch, Harold
2006 Kaytetye. In
Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics, 2nd edn,
Keith
Brown
(ed.), 170–172. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Kornfilt, Jaklin
1997 Turkish [
Descriptive Grammars]. London: Routledge.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Lander, Yuri & Arkadiev, Peter
2016 On the right of being a comparative concept.
Linguistic Typology
20(2): 403–416.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Lee, Que
1997 Dative Constructions and Case Theory in Korean. PhD dissertation, Simon Fraser University.
Lehmann, Christian
2018 Linguistic concepts and categories in language description and comparison. In
Typology, Acquisition, Grammaticalization Studies [
Materiali Linguistici 79],
Marin
Chini &
Pierluigi
Cuzzolin
(eds), 27–50. Milano: Franco Angeli.
[URL] (9 May 2019).
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Maddieson, Ian
2018 Is phonological typology possible without (universal) categories?
In
Phonological Typology [
Phonology and Phonetics 23],
Larry M.
Hyman &
Frans
Plank
(eds), 107–125. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Maiden, Martin
2009 From pure phonology to pure morphology. The reshaping of the Romance verb.
Recherches Linguistiques de Vincennes
38: 45–82.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
McGinn, Colin
2012 Truth by Analysis. Oxford: OUP.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Moravcsik, Edith A.
2016 On linguistic categories. In
Linguistic Typology
20(2): 417–425.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Newmeyer, Frederick J.
2010 On comparative concepts and descriptive categories: A reply to Haspelmath.
Language
86(3): 688–695.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Quine, Willard van Orman
1960 Word and Object [
Series in Communication]. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Reiner, Tabea
2014 Lexical and grammatical meaning. Revisited. In
Semantics and Beyond. Philosophical and Linguistic Investigations [
Philosophical Analysis 57],
Piotr
Stalmaszczyk
(ed), 231–240. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Riemer, Nick
2006 Reductive paraphrase and meaning. A critique of Wierzbickian semantics.
Linguistics and Philosophy
29(3): 347–379.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Rijkhoff, Jan
2016 Crosslinguistic categories in morphosyntactic typology. Problems and prospects. In
Linguistic Typology
20(2): 333–363.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Schachter, Paul
1996 The Subject in Tagalog. Still None of the Above [
UCLA Occasional Papers in Linguistics 15]. Los Angeles: UCLA.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Spencer, Andrew
2008 Does Hungarian have a case system?
In
Case and Grammatical Relations. Studies in Honour of Bernard Comrie [
Typological Studies in Language 81],
Greville G.
Corbett &
Michael
Noonan
(eds), 35–56. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Stassen, Leon
2013 Zero copula for predicate nominals. In
The World Atlas of Language Structures Online,
Matthew S.
Dryer &
Martin
Haspelmath
(eds). Leipzig: MPI for Evolutionary Anthropology.
[URL] (17 January 2019).
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
van der Auwera, Johan & Sahoo, Kalyanamalini
2015 On comparative concepts and descriptive categories, such as they are.
Acta Linguistica Hafniensia
47(2): 136–173.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
van Lier, Eva & Rijkhoff, Jan
2013 Flexible word classes in linguistic typology and grammatical theory. In
Flexible Word Classes. Typological Studies of Underspecified Parts of Speech,
Jan
Rijkhoff &
Eva
van Lier
(eds), 1–30. Oxford: OUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Van Valin, Jr. Robert D.
2005 Exploring the Syntax-semantics Interface. Cambridge: CUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Van Valin, Jr. Robert D. & LaPolla, Randy
1997 Syntax. Structure, Meaning and Function [
Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics]. Cambridge: CUP.
![DOI logo](https://benjamins.com/logos/doi-logo.svg)
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Wade, Terence
1992 A Comprehensive Russian Grammar. Oxford: Blackwell.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Weber, Benjamin
2019 Eine korpuslinguistische Analyse der Wortarten im Hawai’i (A corpus-linguistic analysis of word classes in Hawaiian). Presentation, Munich, 12 July.
Zaefferer, Dietmar
2007 Language as mind sharing device. Mental and linguistic concepts in a general ontology of everyday life. In
Ontolinguistics. How Ontological Status Shapes the Linguistic Coding of Concepts [
Trends in Linguistics; Studies and Monographs 176],
Andrea C.
Schalley &
Dietmar
Zaefferer
(eds), 193–227. Berlin: De Gruyter.
![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Cited by (1)
Cited by 1 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.