Error, feature, (incipient) change – or something else altogether? On the role of low-frequency deviant patterns for the description of Englishes
All corpus linguists routinely come across language use that may, at first sight, appear to be erroneous: planning errors, slips of the tongue/pen or, in the case of contact varieties, evidence of interference from a substrate language. These apparent ‘errors’ are of potential interest because they may, in fact, be on their way of becoming a ‘feature’ of a contact variety or be instances of ongoing change. With respect to change in previous stages of English, we can decide in hindsight which of the three possible scenarios we are dealing with. When it comes to variation in present-day English and possible (ongoing) change, matters are more complicated. In this paper, I present a case study on an unusual auxiliary-participle combination (be been), which has the potential of being an (emergent) feature of contact varieties or an instance of (incipient) language change. I compare two kinds of evidence: acceptability judgements and metalinguistic comments, on the one hand, and data collected from a broad range of corpora, on the other hand. The findings are used not only to discuss grammaticality and norms, but also to reflect on the methodologies employed in the description of World Englishes today.
References
Anderwald, Lieselotte
2014b The decline of the BE-perfect, linguistic relativity, and grammar writing in the 19th century. In
Late Modern English Syntax in Context,
Marianne Hundt (eds), 13–37. Cambridge: CUP.
Atwood, E. Bagby
1953 A Survey of Verb Forms in the Eastern United States. Ann Arbor MI: University of Michigan Press.
Britain, David
2007 Grammatical variation in England. In
Language in the British Isles,
David Britain (eds), 75–104. Cambridge: CUP.
Cassidy, Frederic C
(ed.) 1985 Dictionary of American Regional English. Vol.1, A–C. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Dannenberg, Clare J
2002 Sociolinguistic Constructs of Ethnic Identity: The Syntactic Delineation of an American Indian English [
Publication of the American Dialect Society 87]. Durham NC: Duke University Press.
De Smet, Hendrik
2005 A corpus of Late Modern English.
ICAME Journal 29: 69–82.
Hazen, Kirk
2008 (ING): A vernacular baseline for English in Appalachia.
American Speech 83(2): 116–140.
Hernández, Nuria
2006 User’s Guide to FRED (Freiburg Corpus of English Dialects). Freiburg: Albert-Ludwigs-Universität.
Hoffmann, Sebastian, Hundt, Marianne & Mukherjee, Joybrato
2011 Indian English – an emerging epicentre? A pilot study on light-verbs in web-derived corpora of South Asian Englishes.
Anglia 129: 258–280.
Huber, Magnus
2007 The Old Bailey Proceedings, 1674–1834. Evaluating and annotating a corpus of 18th- and 19th-century spoken English. In
Annotating Variation and Change [
Studies in Variation, Contacts and Change in English 1],
Anneli Meurman-Solin &
Arja Nurmi (eds).
[URL]
Hughes, Arthur, Trudgill, Peter & Watt, Dominic
2005 [1979] English Accents and Dialects: An Introduction to Social and Regional Varieties of English in the British Isles, 4
th edn. London: Arnold.
Hundt, Marianne, Hoffmann, Sebastian & Mukherjee, Joybrato
McCafferty, Kevin & Amador-Moreno, Carolina P
Melchers, Gunnel
2004 English spoken in Orkney and Shetland: Morphology, syntax and lexicon. In
A Handbook of Varieties of English, Vol. 2: Morphology & Syntax,
Bernd Kortmann,
Edgar Schneider,
Kate Burridge,
Rajend Mesthrie &
Clive Upton (eds), 34–47. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Millar, Robert
2007 Northern and Insular Scots. Edinburgh: EUP.
Peitsara, Kirsti & Vasko, Anna-Liisa
2002
The Helsinki Dialect Corpus: Characteristics of speech and aspects of variation.
Helsinki English Studies 2.
[URL]
Robertson, Thomas Argyll & Graham, John
1991 [1952] Grammar and Usage of the Shetland Dialect. Lerwick: Shetland Times.
Sabban, Annette
1984 Investigation into the syntax of Hebridean English.
Scottish Language 3: 5–32.
Schleef, Eric & Flynn, Nicholas
Smith, Jennifer & Durham, Mercedes
2011 A tipping point in dialect obsolescence? Change across the generations in Lerwick, Shetland.
Journal of Sociolinguistics 15(2): 197–225.
Smith, Jennifer & Durham, Mercedes
2012 Bidialectism or dialect death? Explaining generational change in the Shetland Islands, Scotland.
American Speech 87(1): 57–88.
Tagliamonte, Sali
1997 Obsolescence in the English perfect? Evidence from Samaná English.
American Speech 72(1): 33–68.
Warner, Anthony R
1995 Predicting the progressive passive: Parametric change within a lexicalist framework.
Language 71: 533–557.
Wolfram, Walt
1996 Delineation and description in dialectology: The case of Perfective I’m in Lumbee English.
American Speech 71(1): 5–26.
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 21 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.