Cover not available
Part of
Developmental Perspectives in Written Language and Literacy: In honor of Ludo Verhoeven
Edited by Eliane Segers and Paul van den Broek
[Not in series 206] 2017
► pp. 103–118

Hunting for the links between word-level writing skills and text quality

| | Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona
| | Universitat de Barcelona

A recurring claim in developmental models of written composition is that text quality depends to a large extent on efficient word-level writing skills (handwriting and spelling), at least in the early grades. In this chapter, we show that this assumption has a weak empirical basis because of (1) the unsystematic way in which the quality of written texts has been assessed, and (2) the inconclusiveness of findings about the word-text writing relationship in developmental studies of writing. We claim that the demands of transcription have been overestimated, while the explanatory power of high-level components has been majorly overlooked. We conclude that it is the command of high-level text features and skills what makes learning to write a complex, life-long process.

Keywords: early writing, text quality, word-level, text-level
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Assessing the quality of written texts
    • 2.1Holistic scoring
    • 2.2Analytic scoring
  • 3.The impact of transcription skills on writing quality
    • 3.1Spoken and written text quality
  • 4.Going beyond low-level components to explain text quality
    • 4.1High-level writing processes: Task schemas and topic knowledge
    • 4.2Working memory and executive functions
  • 5.Concluding remarks
  • Note
  • References
Published online: 21 December 2017
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/z.206.07sal
References
Abbott, R. D., Berninger, V. W., & Fayol, M
(2010) Longitudinal relationships of levels of language in writing and between writing and reading in grades 1 to 7. Journal of Educational Psychology, 102(2), 281–298. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Alamargot, D., & Chanquoy, L
(2001) Through the models of writing: With commentaries by Ronald T. Kellogg & John R. Hayes (Vol. 9). Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Academic. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Alloway, T. P., Gathercole, S. E., Adams, A. M., Willis, C., Eaglen, R., & Lamont, E
(2005) Working memory and phonological awareness as predictors of progress towards early learning goals at school entry. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 23(3), 417–426. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Alves, R. A., Castro, S. L., de Sousa, L., & Strömqvist, S
(2007) The cognitive cost of execution in written composition. In Recent developments in writing process research (Vol. 1. Basic processes and word level effects). Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Academic.Google Scholar
Andriessen, J., & Coirier, P
(Eds.) (1999) Foundations of argumentative text processing. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.Google Scholar
Babayiğit, S., & Stainthorp, R
(2010) Component processes of early reading, spelling, and narrative writing skills in Turkish: A longitudinal study. International Journal of Reading and Writing, 23(5), 539–568. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(2011) Modeling the relationships between cognitive–linguistic skills and literacy skills: New insights from a transparent orthography. Journal of Educational Psychology, 103(1), 169–189. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Beers, S. F., & Nagy, W. E
(2009) Syntactic complexity as a predictor of adolescent writing quality: Which measures? Which genre? International Journal of Reading and Writing, 22(2), 185–200. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berman, R., & Nir, B
(2009) Cognitive and linguistic factors in evaluating text quality: Global versus local? In V. Evans & S. Pourcel (Eds.), New directions in cognitive linguistics (pp. 421–440). Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berninger, V. W., & Swanson, H. L
(1994) Modifying Hayes and Flower’s model of skilled writing to explain beginning and developing writing. Advances in cognition and educational practice, 2, 57–81.Google Scholar
Berninger, V. W., Mizokawa, D. T., & Bragg, R
(1991) Scientific practitioner: Theory-based diagnosis and remediation of writing disabilities. Journal of School Psychology, 29(1), 57–79. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berninger, V. W., Vaughan, K. B., Abbott, R. D., Abbott, S. P., Woodruff Rogan, L., Brooks, A., & Reed, E
(1997) Treatment of handwriting problems in beginning writers: Transfer from Handwriting to Composition. Journal of Educational Psychology, 89, 652–666. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berninger, V. W., Vaughan, K., Abbott, R. D., Begay, K., Coleman, K. B., Curtin, G., Hawkins, J. M., & Graham, S
(2002) Teaching spelling and composition alone and together: Implications for the simple view of writing. Journal of Educational Psychology, 94(2), 291–304. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berninger, V. W., & Amtmann, D
(2003) Preventing written expression disabilities through early and continuing assessment and intervention for handwriting and/or spelling problems: Research into practice. In H. L. Swanson, S. Graham, & K. R. Harris (Eds.), Handbook of learning disabilities (pp. 345–363). New York: Guilford.Google Scholar
Berninger, V., & Winn, W
(2006) Implications of advancements in brain research and technology for writing development, writing instruction, and educational evolution. In C. MacArthur, S. Graham, & J. Fitzgerald (Eds.), Handbook of writing research (pp. 96–114). New York: Guilford.Google Scholar
Berninger, V., Yates, C., Cartwright, A., Rutberg, J., Remy, E., & Abbott, R
(1992) Lower-level developmental skills in beginning writing. International Journal of Reading and writing, 4(3), 257–280. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Blanche Benveniste, C
(1982) La escritua del lenguaje dominguero. In E. Ferreiro (Ed.), Nuevas Perspectivas Sobre los Procesos de Lectura y Escritura (pp. 195–212). Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI.Google Scholar
Borzone de Manrique, A. M., & Diuk, B
(2003) La escritura de textos en niños pequeños: conocimiento ortográfico y producción textual. Composition in young children: Spelling and text production. Cultura y Educación, 15(1), 17–27. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Borzone de Manrique, A. M., & Signorini, A
(1998) Emergent writing forms in Spanish. Reading and Writing, 10(6), 499–517. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Boscolo, P
(1990) The construction of expository text. First Language, 10(30), 217–230. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bourdin, B., & Fayol, M
(2002) Even in adults, written production is still more costly than oral production. International Journal of Psychology, 37(4), 219–227. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bourke, L., & Adams, A-M
(2003) The relationship between working memory and early writing assessed at the word, sentence and text level. Educational and Child Psychology, 20(3), 19–36.Google Scholar
Caravolas, M., Lervåg, A., Mousikou, P., Efrim, C., Litavský, M., Onochie-Quintanilla, E., Salas, N., Schöffelová, M., Defior, S., Mikulajová, M., Seidlová-Málková, G., & Hulme, C
(2012) Common patterns of prediction of literacy development in different alphabetic orthographies. Psychological Science, 23(6), 678–686. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chafe, W
(1994) Discourse, consciousness, and time: The flow of language in speech and writing. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.Google Scholar
Charney, D
(1984) The validity of using holistic scoring to evaluate writing: A critical overview. Research in the Teaching of English, 18(1), 65–81.Google Scholar
Connelly, V., Dockrell, J. E., Walter, K., & Critten, S
(2012) Predicting the quality of composition and written language bursts from oral language, spelling, and handwriting skills in children with and without specific language impairment. Written Communication, 29(3), 278–302. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
DeGroff, L. J. C
(1987) The influence of prior knowledge on writing, conferencing, and revising. The Elementary School Journal, 88(2), 105–118. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dunsmuir, S., & Blatchford, P
(2004) Predictors of writing competence in 4‐to 7‐year‐old children. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 74(3), 461–483. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Espin, C. A., Weissenburger, J. W., & Benson, B. J
(2004) Assessing the writing performance of students in special education. Exceptionality, 12(1), 55–66.Google Scholar
Fayol, M
(1999) From on-line management problems to strategies in written production. In M. Torrance & G. Jeffery (Eds.), Cognitive demands of writing. Processing capacity and working memory effects in text production (pp. 13–24). Amsterdam: Amsterdam University.Google Scholar
Freedman, S. W
(1979) How characteristics of student essays influence teachers’ evaluations. Journal of Educational Psychology, 71(3), 328–338. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Freedman, S. W., & Calfee, R. C
(1983) Holistic assessment of writing: Experimental design and cognitive theory. In P. Mosenthal, L. Tamor, & S. A. Walmsley (Eds.), Research in writing: Principles and methods (pp. 75–98). New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Grabowski, J., Becker-Mrotzek, M., Knopp, M., Jost, J., & Weinzierl, C
(2014) Comparing and combining different approaches to the assessment of text quality. In D. Knorr, C. Heine, & J. Engberg (Eds.), Methods in writing process research (pp. 147–165). Frankfurt/M.: Lang.Google Scholar
Graham, S
(1990) The role of production factors in learning disabled students’ compositions. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82(4), 781–791. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Graham, S. & Harris, K. R
(2000) The role of self-regulation and transcription skills in writing and writing development. Educational Psychologist, 35(1), 3–12. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Graham, S., & Weintraub, N
(1996) A review of handwriting research: Progress and prospects from 1980 to 1994. Educational Psychology Review, 8(1), 7–87. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Graham, S., Berninger, V. W., Abbott, R. D., Abbott, S. P., & Whitaker, D
(1997) Role of mechanics in composing of elementary school students: A new methodological approach. Journal of Educational Psychology, 89(1), 170–182. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Griffin, T. M., Hemphill, L., Camp, L., & Wolf, D. P
(2004) Oral discourse in the preschool years and later literacy skills. First Language, 24(2), 123–147. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hayes, J. R
(2012) Modeling and remodeling writing. Written Communication, 29(3), 369–388. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hayes, J. R., & Flower, L. S
(1980) Identifying the organization of writing processes. In L. W. Gregg & E. R. Steinberg (Eds.), Cognitive processes in writing (pp. 3–30). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Hildyard, A., & Hidi, S
(1985) Oral-written differences in the production and recall of narratives. In D. R. Olson, N. Torrance, & A. Hildyard (Eds.), Literacy, language, and learning: The nature and consequences of reading and writing (pp. 285–306). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Hooper, S. R., Roberts, J. E., Nelson, L., Zeisel, S., & Fannin, D. K
(2010) Preschool predictors of narrative writing skills in elementary school children. School Psychology Quarterly, 25, 1–12. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hooper, S. R., Costa, L. J., McBee, M., Anderson, K. L., Yerby, D. C., Knuth, S. B., & Childress, A
(2011) Concurrent and longitudinal neuropsychological contributors to written language expression in first and second grade students. International Journal of Reading and writing, 24, 221–252. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jones, D., & Christensen, C. A
(1999) Relationship between automaticity in handwriting and students’ ability to generate written text. Journal of Educational Psychology, 91(1), 44–49. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Juel, C., Griffith, P. L., & Gough, P. B
(1986) Acquisition of literacy: A longitudinal study of children in first and second grade. Journal of Educational Psychology, 78(4), 243–255. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Katzenberger, I
1994 Cognitive, linguistic, and developmental factors in the narration of picture-series. Tel Aviv University doctoral dissertation [in Hebrew].
Kent, S., Wanzek, J., Petscher, Y., Al Otaiba, S., & Kim, Y. S
(2014) Writing fluency and quality in kindergarten and first grade: The role of attention, reading, transcription, and oral language. International Journal of Reading and writing, 27(7), 1163–1188. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Y. S., Al Otaiba, S., Puranik, C., Folsom, J. S., Greulich, L., & Wagner, R. K
(2011) Componential skills of beginning writing: An exploratory study. Learning and Individual Differences, 21(5), 517–525. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Y. S., Al Otaiba, S., Folsom, J. S., Greulich, L., & Puranik, C
(2014) Evaluating the dimensionality of first-grade written composition. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 57(1), 199–211. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Y. S., Al Otaiba, S., & Wanzek, J
(2015a) Kindergarten predictors of third grade writing. Learning and Individual Differences, 37, 27–37. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Y. S., Al Otaiba, S., & Wanzek, J
(2015b) Kindergarten predictors of third grade writing. Learning and Individual Differences, 37, 27–37. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Landerl, K., & Wimmer, H
(2008) Development of word reading fluency and spelling in a consistent orthography: An 8-year follow-up. Journal of Educational Psychology, 100(1), 150–161. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Langer, J. A
(1984) Effects of topic knowledge on the quality and coherence of informational writing. In N. A. Appelbee (Ed.), Contexts for learning to write (pp. 79–102). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.Google Scholar
Lerkkanen, M. K., Rasku‐Puttonen, H., Aunola, K., & Nurmi, J. E
(2004) The developmental dynamics of literacy skills during the first grade. Educational Psychology, 24(6), 793–810. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Limpo, T., & Alves, R. A
(2013) Modeling writing development: Contribution of transcription and self-regulation to Portuguese students’ text generation quality. Journal of Educational Psychology, 105(2), 401–413. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mäki, H. S., Voeten, M. J., Vauras, M. M., & Poskiparta, E. H
(2001) Predicting writing skill development with word recognition and preschool readiness skills. International Journal of Reading and Writing, 14(7–8), 643–672. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Malvern, D., Richards, B. J., Chipere, N., & Durán, P
(2004) Lexical diversity and language development. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McColly, W
(1970) What does educational research say about the judging of writing ability? Journal of Educational Research, 64(4), 148–156. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McCutchen, D
(1986) Domain knowledge and linguistic knowledge in the development of writing ability. Journal of Memory and Language, 25(4), 431–444. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(1996) A capacity theory of writing: Working memory in composition. Educational Psychology Review, 8(3), 299–325. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(2000) Knowledge, processing, and working memory: Implications for a theory of writing. Educational Psychologist, 35, 13–23. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McCutchen, D., Covill, A., Hoyne, S. H., & Mildes, K
(1994) Individual differences in writing: Implications of translating fluency. Journal of Educational Psychology, 86(2), 256–266. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McNamara, D. S., Crossley, S. A., & McCarthy, P. M
(2010) Linguistic features of writing quality. Written Communication, 27(1), 57–86. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Myers, M
(1980) A procedure for writing assessment and holistic scoring. Urbana, IL: ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and Communication Skills, and the National Council of Teachers of English.Google Scholar
Odell, L
(1981) How English teachers can help their colleagues teach writing. In P. Stock (Ed.), Forum: Essays on theory and practice in the teaching of writing. Upper Montclair, NJ: Boynton/Cook.Google Scholar
Olinghouse, N. G., & Leaird, J. T
(2009) The relationship between measures of vocabulary and narrative writing quality in second-and fourth-grade students. International Journal of Reading and Writing, 22(5), 545–565. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Olive, T
(2004) Working memory in writing: Empirical evidence from the dual-task technique. European Psychologists, 9, 32–42. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Olive, T., & Kellogg, R. T
(2002) Concurrent activation of high-and low-level production processes in written composition. Memory & Cognition, 30(4), 594–600. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Olive, T., Favart, M., Beauvais, C., & Beauvais, L
(2009) Children’s cognitive effort and fluency in writing: Effects of genre and of handwriting automatisation. Learning and Instruction, 19(4), 299–308. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Puranik, C. S., & AlOtaiba, S
(2012) Examining the contribution of handwriting and spelling to written expression in kindergarten children. International Journal of Reading and writing, 25(7), 1523–1546. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Puranik, C. S., Lombardino, L. J., & Altmann, L. J
(2008) Assessing the microstructure of written language using a retelling paradigm. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 17(2), 107–120. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Puranik, C. S
(2006) Expository writing skills in elementary school children from Third through sixth grades and contributions of short-term and working memory. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. University of Florida.
Ravid, D., & Katzenberger, I
(1999) Global text evaluation. In R. Aisenman (Ed.), Developing literacy across genres, modalities, and languages. Working papers (Vol. I, pp. 220–224). Tel Aviv University: International Literacy Project.Google Scholar
Ravid, D., & Berman, R. A
(2010) Developing noun phrase complexity at school age: A text-embedded cross-linguistic analysis. First Language, 30(1), 3–26. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Salas, N
(2010) Cognitive and discoursive underpinnings of Spanish noun-phrases. Unpublished Masters’ Dissertation. University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.Google Scholar
(2014) Early writing development in two contrasting orthographies: English and Spanish. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. Bangor University, United Kingdom.Google Scholar
Salas, N., Llauradó, A., Castillo, C., Taulé, M., & Martí, M. A
(2016) Linguistic correlates of text quality from childhood to adulthood. In J. Perera, M. Aparici, E. Rosado, & N. Salas (Eds.), Written and spoken language development across the life-span. Essays in honour of Liliana Tolchinsky (pp. 307–326). Amsterdam: Springer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sánchez-Abchi, V., Borzone, A. M., & Diuk, B
(2007) La escritura de textos en niños pequeños: relación entre la transcripción y la composición [Text writing in small children: Relationships between transcription and composition]. Universitas psychologica, 3, 559–569.Google Scholar
Scardamalia, M., Bereiter, C., & Goelman, H
(1982) The role of production factors in writing ability. In M. Nystrand (Ed.), What writers know: The language, process, and structure of written discourse (pp. 173–210). New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Scott, C. M
(2009) Language-based assessment of written expression. Instruction and assessment for struggling writers: Evidence-based practices (pp. 358–385). New York: Guilford.Google Scholar
Strömqvist, S., Johansson, V., Kriz, S., Ragnarsdottir, H., Aisenman, R., & Ravid, D
(2002) Toward a cross-linguistic comparison of lexical quantain speech and writing. Written Language & Literacy, 5(1), 45–67. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Swanson, H. L., & Berninger, V. W
(1996) Individual differences in children’s working memory and writing skill. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 63(2), 358–385. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wagner, R. K., Puranik, C. S., Foorman, B., Foster, E., Wilson, L. G., Tschinkel, E., & Kantor, P. T
(2011) Modeling the development of written language. International Journal of Reading and Writing, 24(2), 203–220. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cited by

Cited by 3 other publications

Alonso-Cortés-Fradejas, M. Dolores, Mercedes López-Aguado & M. Teresa Llamazares-Prieto
2021. Vocabulary depth and its contribution to text quality in the early years of primary school (Profundidad de vocabulario y su contribución a la calidad textual en los primeros años de Educación Primaria). Journal for the Study of Education and Development 44:1 ► pp. 82 ff. DOI logo
Castillo, Cristina & Liliana Tolchinsky
2018. The contribution of vocabulary knowledge and semantic orthographic fluency to text quality through elementary school in Catalan. Reading and Writing 31:2 ► pp. 293 ff. DOI logo
Zadunaisky-Ehrlich, Sara, Batia Seroussi & Anat Stavans
2021. Predictors of spelling errors in expository texts written by Hebrew-speaking elementary school children (Predictores de errores ortográficos en textos expositivos escritos por alumnos de habla hebrea en escuela primaria). Journal for the Study of Education and Development 44:1 ► pp. 117 ff. DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 march 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.